I was playing a bit with Spring DI and Quarkus before Christmas. I took repo referenced from baeldung.com site, trimmed the code and pom.xml to use just di.spring package. After the trimming I tried to migrate source code to use quarkus-spring and then I tried to migrate tests. I have ideas for enhancements in Spring DI guide
Based on the discussion with @geoand, @ComponentScan is entirely unnecessary because of the build time processing. @Import is not supported as we don't support XML config.
Info about @ComponentScan and @Import should be added into https://quarkus.io/guides/spring-di#conversion-table or nearby. People without Quarkus context won't know the above details and it will make Quarkus onboarding easier.
ApplicationContext
There is nothing about org.springframework.context.ApplicationContext in our guides. We don't support that - it's too tied to Spring internals. Spring DI guide should provide some context and explain into what ApplicationContext translates in Arc / Quarkus DI world.
Testing
For tests, we don't support any of the Spring testing stuff. It's just so different than what we have in Quarkus.
https://quarkus.io/guides/getting-started-testing could be linked from the guide.
I was playing a bit with Spring DI and Quarkus before Christmas. I took repo referenced from baeldung.com site, trimmed the code and pom.xml to use just di.spring package. After the trimming I tried to migrate source code to use quarkus-spring and then I tried to migrate tests. I have ideas for enhancements in Spring DI guide
Code is here: https://github.com/rsvoboda/tutorials/commits/experiments
@ComponentScanand@ImportIn https://github.com/rsvoboda/tutorials/commit/68c9f76fdcd181b4dc913977f564f09705784beb I had to comment out org.springframework.context.annotation.ComponentScan and org.springframework.context.annotation.Import stuffBased on the discussion with @geoand,
@ComponentScanis entirely unnecessary because of the build time processing.@Importis not supported as we don't support XML config.Info about
@ComponentScanand@Importshould be added into https://quarkus.io/guides/spring-di#conversion-table or nearby. People without Quarkus context won't know the above details and it will make Quarkus onboarding easier.ApplicationContext There is nothing about
org.springframework.context.ApplicationContextin our guides. We don't support that - it's too tied to Spring internals. Spring DI guide should provide some context and explain into what ApplicationContext translates in Arc / Quarkus DI world.Testing For tests, we don't support any of the Spring testing stuff. It's just so different than what we have in Quarkus. https://quarkus.io/guides/getting-started-testing could be linked from the guide.
https://github.com/quarkusio/quarkus/issues/14221
$upstream:14221$