softsyst / qirx_issues

Issue tracker for QIRX
1 stars 1 forks source link

Feature suggestion: MOT Slides Analyzer for DAB #145

Closed salvaaod closed 6 months ago

salvaaod commented 9 months ago

There is one feature that I will love to see in QIRX, audio and PAD slide análisis DabPlayer from Andreas Gsinn does, it, the feature is the capability to analyze actual audio bitrate and PAD, being able to see the size of MOT (silide) downloaded and graphics, Below is a photo of the PAD analyzer, you can see the total channel Bitrate, the Slide Bitrate and size downloaded, and the audio bitrate.

Thanks for your consideration.

image

image

softsyst commented 9 months ago

Thanks for your input. I will make an estimate for the effort and decide accordingly. Most of it seems useful to me, what I will probably omit is the numbers above the progress bar, which would influence the GUI design of the "Service" tab. A progress bar is already provided.

salvaaod commented 9 months ago

Actually the data that it will be desired will be: Service Bitrate (already provided) Actual Audio Bitrate PAD Bitrate Slide size being downloaded *% and data downloaded of the current slide.

The Audio bitrate and PAD Bitrate will have to have into account the RS overhead. This will give a detail about the actual audio quality and PAD overhead.

BR.

softsyst commented 9 months ago

After a look into the efforts, also considering possible GUI drawbacks, I suggest the following enhancements:

What will not be implemented is the % and data of the download rate, and slide sizes. The pictures can be stored, and the % of the download rate can well be estimated from the progress bar.

salvaaod commented 9 months ago

Thanks Clem, I think this will be a great feature.

softsyst commented 6 months ago

Implemented in 4.2.2