solana-labs / oyster

oyster.vercel.app
Apache License 2.0
116 stars 127 forks source link

.5 pBTC is not distinguishible after sending through the wormhole eth to salano #370

Closed apollo711 closed 2 years ago

apollo711 commented 3 years ago

Really long story short ... tried to farm on Saber renBTC to pBTC. When bringing the assets over the bridge that was Wormhole V1 the pBTC became unwrapped and no longer is distinguishable as pBTC or BTC. I tried to reach out to Saber, NO HELP! Tried to find Parrot on discord and wow, not even sure what to say about that. So weird, I guess there are two firms both doing something with pBTC? Anyway, I contacted the wrong parrot. Went back to Saber, still no help. Tried contacting Wormhole. Where I got some direction from https://github.com/leoluk but after a few weeks he informs ... We do not maintain the Wormhole v1 UI, raise an issue here: https://github.com/solana-labs/oyster/issues. So here is where I am! You will find most of the details at the link below. I will spare you the details of discussion in discord with Saber as you will find it of no value and a complete unproductive waste of time. Saber provided NO direction what-so-ever. I look forward to hearing back from someone from Solana with some positive news.

https://github.com/certusone/wormhole

https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/47486784/135700849-a2cef433-3b29-4a1f-813a-7f350062044d.mp4

https://1drv.ms/v/s!Ar8pGyjRm3fhgrlVMlJ6JrtQhfkqNg?e=3f1nsR

leoluk commented 2 years ago

User needs pBTC in the v1 token picker.

apollo711 commented 2 years ago

Hello Leo I have made many attempts at getting this coin sent back through the v1 wormhole. I have tried employing the help of SS in the wormhole telegram but there are many scammers in the cesspool that is telegram and having had many try to scam me I'm not confident in the security and reliability of the platform. Besides the fundamental issues with the v1 platform and it's instability I have had much trouble trying to make it work. I think I can say with confidence that what it boils down to is the I can not select the token because the token picker is not configured to pick a coin that is no longer identifiable. v1 is configured for a limited number of tokens. I cannot select a coin/token whatever it is, that the wormhole is not configured to select. I have spent countless hours trying to find a way to make this work. I am not a developer and do not have the necessary technical expertise to develop the code that may or may not allow this to work. Even if the token picker is somehow configured to select the coin that what was once pBTC, there is no guarantee that sending it back through the portal will fix the issue. Although there have been great progress in the development of the wormhole protocol I have suspected sense early on that the team was under a lot of pressure to role out the protocol as the Solana blockchain was greatly dependent upon the wormhole to bring non-native assets onto the Solana ecosystem and thereby adding significant total value locked (TVL). But this rush to market has consequences and I have long been a victim of those consequences. I have tried to do whatever I can to make progress and to come up with a solution. Unfortunately I do not possess the necessary technical skills to bring this issue to resolution. It's time for Solana, Wormhole, and Sabor to be held to accountability and to do something more to resolve the issue. Until you have the the undistinguishable token in your custody it will be difficult to determine resolution. I propose we swap the .5 undistinguishable pBTC for an equal amount of bitcoin. This will allow you to test and evaluate and decide if making the necessary v1 configuration changes is will allow the coin to be restored at the same time making me whole and resolving my issue. Please advise how you would like to proceed.

apollo711 commented 2 years ago

Leo I have tried to get this issue looked at on the certusone/wormhole github and I thought I had an open issue here but I don't see it. I'm not a developer so my github skills suck to say the least. This thing is way old. Can someone please look at it? HELP!!