solgenomics / sgn

The code behind the Sol Genomics Network, Cassavabase and other Breedbase websites
https://solgenomics.net
MIT License
66 stars 35 forks source link

Musabase-btract: cross wish list improvements #2268

Closed bauchetg closed 5 years ago

bauchetg commented 5 years ago

Expected Behavior

-> The wishlist physical field map does not display field information correctly: ex: https://musabase-test.sgn.cornell.edu/breeders/trial/481?format= The trial coordinates are loaded and field map is correct but its display on the wishlist does not reflect that: it uses block info rather row/column info (see screen shot below).

-> Wish list upload transfer to ONA/btract Once user proceed to file transfer there is no clear message just a “Working” dialog Something like “ your wish list is being transfer to ODK/Btract server” would clarify. This is very confusing users who usually believe that they have to download it themselves using the following popup

screen shot 2018-11-19 at 11 26 37 am



-> seeds harvested and embryo rescued terminology and ID storage: "Embryo rescue" term is incorrect and should be replace by "Embryo culture" -Only "Good Seeds" ( and not "Embryo rescue good seeds") can be used for "Embryo culture" -Practically each seed harvested go through embryo rescue (=<50 seeds) or to the nursery (50+). -Each seed requires a unique ID no matter what will work or not. -Several other terms required edits @mkaranja can you provide these?

For Bugs:

Environment

Steps to Reproduce

nickmorales commented 5 years ago
  1. Both options whether "using lists" or "not using lists" rely on "crossing block information", so I think that change would be confusing.

  2. The requirement for the dynamic checkbox in each cell made it sufficiently different that I could not use the old/new field map tools. Maybe the new BrAPP field map solves this issue, but it is complicated.

  3. Would just saying something like this be enough?: "If you selected an ODK ONA form on the first menu, then your cross wishlist is available to use from ODK ONA mobile applications. If you are not using ODK ONA, then you can download the files from here to plan your crossing."

I would recommend breaking this ticket into smaller tickets because long tickets are hard to close.

bauchetg commented 5 years ago

@nickmorales

  1. Current naming is rather unclear to users, since it is requested we need to change this naming, perhaps "crossing block information" can be replaced by a more general "using field experiment". "Not using list" is rather counter intuitive.

  2. Would rather not have a display since the one we have is actually incorrect. Or can it be displayed using the row/cols, that would be fine? The new field map is probably difficult to wire in this? @dauglyon ?

  3. This too many details and too much technical linguo, users are not really familiar with oDK, ONA, and dont need to be, something simpler like "Your wishlist is been sent to BTracT server " and "Optionally you can files download here:"

Ok doing that!