search

solid / data-interoperability-panel

Repository for the Solid Data Interoperability Panel
MIT License
51 stars 19 forks source link

Comparison with ESS Access Requests and Grants #317

Open michielbdejong opened 1 year ago

michielbdejong commented 1 year ago

I was just reading https://docs.inrupt.com/ess/latest/security/access-requests-grants/ and it seemed that ESS access requests:

An agent sends an access request to the resource owner. In ESS, the access request is serialized as a VC.

are quite similar to this panel's Data Needs:

A given Social Agent or Application expresses their access needs by providing one or more Access Need Groups to the Social Agent controlling the data they require access to.

And that ESS access grants:

For an approved request, ESS creates an access grant with an approved status.

are quite similar to this panel's Access Authorizations:

An Access Authorization records the decision of a Social Agent to grant access to some portion of data in their control to another Agent.

Given the existence of these two apparently similar systems within our project's community, would maybe it make sense to create a library that abstracts the differences and can deal with both transparently?

woutermont commented 1 year ago

I believe one of the first things to do once the WG starts, is to align these two models. They are almost identical in approach differing only in some naming and parameters. I would have loved to do that in the context of the CG / Interop Panel, but Inrupt apparently does not.