search

solid / solid-wg-charter

Proposed charter for the W3C Solid Working Group
Other
10 stars 7 forks source link

Open session to discuss and promote Solid WG charter proposal #68

Open csarven opened 7 months ago

csarven commented 7 months ago

Perhaps this is something @pchampin (W3C Team) can follow up on to widely communicate in a public space where anyone interested can discuss and coordinate even if it is just an informative session. Explain progress since https://www.w3.org/2023/09/proposed-solid-wg-charter.html e.g., outline significant objections / concerns are (being) addressed as well as the work/proposal ahead, including Solid CG (and friends) decisions and W3C Team Decisions.

Considering using these kinds of important sessions to promote the WG charter to the W3C community, as well as to gather and incorporate feedback prior to making the second (upcoming) Solid WG charter proposal.

There was https://www.w3.org/2024/01/webevolve-series-events/solid.html but I don't see a record of this event being mentioned to the public Solid CG or any particular feedback to the Solid CG or the Solid WG charter. Perhaps it wasn't necessary or useful.

There is W3C Breakouts Day 2024 on 2024-03-12 for breakout sessions, I suggest proposing a session towards this end. More details at https://github.com/w3c/breakouts-day-2024 Example proposal for WG charter: https://github.com/w3c/breakouts-day-2024/issues/3

melvincarvalho commented 7 months ago

I was hoping the WG would start up in early 2024, and then get to REC in Q1 2026 since it already has 2 implementations and a test suite.

Are you saying that you think the WG will still not be chartered by mid March?

pchampin commented 7 months ago

@csarven I'd be happy to have this conversation. The W3C breakout day is indeed a good opportunity, althouh I kinda hope we can be into horizontal review already at that point, or even AC review (though the latter seems overly optimistic).

@melvincarvalho given that the minimum delay for the AC review is 28 days, we will definitely not have a WG mid March. But as I write above, I hope we have some progress towards that by then.

Re. the WebEvolve meeting about Solid, I concur that it would have been nice to advertise it to the CG. Note however that the event was mostly in Chinese (apart from my presentation), and Zoom's live translation was only barely helpful...

melvincarvalho commented 2 months ago

Can this be closed?

hzbarcea commented 2 months ago

Yes, it can and should be.