Instantiation params don't work

sonata-nfv / tng-portal

The 5GTANGO (web) Portal

Apache License 2.0

1 stars 7 forks source link

Instantiation params don't work #472

Closed stefanbschneider closed 5 years ago

stefanbschneider commented 5 years ago

It seems like passing instantiation params via the portal doesn't work.

I just tested it with NS2 of the industry pilot and passed parameter "MQTT_BROKER_HOST": "10.200.16.31", which should set the env var of the instance accordingly.

Still, when checking the instantiated VNF, the env var was not set correctly:

root@eu-5gtango-smpilot-mdc-0-1-658a7b60-b875c989f-rhlpt:/# env | grep MQTT
MQTT_BROKER_PORT=1883
MQTT_BROKER_HOST=172.31.13.158

It works fine when using tng-cli with the --params_file flag.

Belongs to #443

anapolg commented 5 years ago

Hi, some questions: Which environment? Which instantiation? NS or slices?

stefanbschneider commented 5 years ago

Hi, some questions: Which environment?

https://int-sp-ath.5gtango.eu

Which instantiation? NS or slices?

NS, eg, https://int-sp-ath.5gtango.eu/service-management/network-services/services/a5d565d6-aa5e-4204-b3d9-c3a8fcf9f853

anapolg commented 5 years ago

Hi, I've just merged what I think is the solution to your problem. Can you please try again whenever possible and confirm me if it works for you? (It should be deployed in both pre-int and int environments).

stefanbschneider commented 5 years ago

Hi, thanks!

I just tested on int, and it still didn't work. The env var is still unchanged

# env | grep MQTT
MQTT_BROKER_PORT=1883
MQTT_BROKER_HOST=172.31.13.158

anapolg commented 5 years ago

Then I think we need someone else cause I saw the request sent and I am sending the params as:

So I see no error from Portal side that I am aware off...

stefanbschneider commented 5 years ago

I just checked your service on k8s and it worked!

localadmin@k8s-master:~$ kubectl -it exec eu-5gtango-smpilot-mdc-0-1-f83d83d7-868dd8cf48-g4s9l bash
root@eu-5gtango-smpilot-mdc-0-1-f83d83d7-868dd8cf48-g4s9l:/# env | grep MQTT
MQTT_BROKER_PORT=1883
MQTT_BROKER_HOST=10.200.16.31

Not sure where I went wrong, but I guess this is solved now. I'll try again with the Portal next time and let you know if it doesn't work then.

Thanks for the quick help :)

anapolg commented 5 years ago

Mmmm I think I might know... you should try reloading your Portal tab with CTRL+SHIFT/MAYUS+R... Your Portal version might be yet the old one and it did not get updated. This happens sometimes...