sophiabrothers1 / 2023mayoralelection

0 stars 0 forks source link

Peer review 2 #1

Open DJY1231 opened 1 day ago

DJY1231 commented 1 day ago

Opening statement summary

Overall your paper seem to be half finished but need improvements.

Strong positive points

I see you have updated your paper.pdf (introduction, data, and appendix) so I can tell what you're trying to do in your paper. Scripts, data, and llm parts are updated so it's a good start.

Critical improvements needed

It would be better to see some work updated as soon as possible, for example, your abstract in the paper, paper.qmd, readme, and other parts besides the one I mentioned.

Suggestions for improvement:

You should bring ba

Please consider adding/changing/removing:

Update your datasheet, literature, llm, sketches, README, and paper. Try to bring back literature, sketches, and datasheet if you are willing to use it.

Evaluation:

If you update your abstract of your paper and make it overall organized, the overall mark will increase. Just need some updates on the ones I mentioned above.

Estimated mark:

30 out of 100.

Reason:

he paper is halfway finished; however, it needs updates, as well as improvements to your overall 2023mayoralelection page.