space-concordia-robotics / robotics-prototype

Teleoperated Mars rover with autonomous capabilities intended for robotics competitions.
https://spaceconcordia.github.io/robotics.html
25 stars 18 forks source link

Make the Serial available check before every Serial.read() #516

Closed MewtR closed 3 years ago

MewtR commented 3 years ago

Assignee Section

Description

Fixes the issue of getting garbage when back to back Serial.read()s are performed. If you Serial.read() before it's "ready" you run the risk of reading garbage values.

Steps for Testing

Note: I tested using an Arduino Nano. I don't know what happens with a teensy. Also you need some code that links to and uses the internal comms library found in robot/rover/internal_comms/

  1. In robot/rover/internal_comms/src/CommandCenter.cpp replace all instances of waitForSerial() with Serial.read()
  2. Serial.print the two bytes inside readArgSize()
  3. Compile and upload your program.
  4. Run it, send in some bytes and you should see that you get corrupted values. In other words you don't get the same as the bytes you sent in.
  5. Undo changes from 1
  6. Run the experiment again. You should get the values you sent in this time

Additional info

It's not trivial to use the Arduino IDE for the testing steps above so I had to do everything from the commandline. Here's how:

Compiling

Use the provided Cmakelists.txt. These generate elf files

Uploading

The arduino ide will only upload a binary it compiled itself so we need to manually upload with avrdude. My command looked like the following avrdude -C/home/bionic/arduino-1.8.12/hardware/tools/avr/etc/avrdude.conf -v -patmega328p -carduino -P/dev/ttyUSB0 -b57600 -D -Uflash:w:bin/PDS2.elf:e. Just remember to change the device from /dev/ttyUSB0 to whatever your device is and the path to avrdude.conf to the path on your system. Also put the path to your elf file in the last part : -Uflash:w:<path/to/elf.elf>:e

Sending bytes

The Arduino IDE's serial monitor only allows you to send ascii as far as I can tell. So I used python to send in raw bytes. Basically in one terminal you should have tail -f <device> so for example tail -f /dev/ttyUSB0. In another terminal you can run something like: python3 -c "import sys; sys.stdout.buffer.write(b'\x36\x00\x02\x00\x02\x06\x64\x00')" > /dev/ttyUSB0 and you should see any results in the first terminal. If you don't see anything despite having some prints. Try sending data via the Serial monitor first and then retry this method.

closes nothing

The approval from all software team leads is necessary before merging.

Reviewer Section

Aside from local testing and the General Integration Test it is implied that static analysis should be included in the verification process.

For Pull Requests that do not include code changes, it is not required to perform the tests above.