Closed licaon-kter closed 1 year ago
Just to be clear, what is the app doing now that is not like this?
On Tue, Dec 1, 2015, 16:43 licaon-kter notifications@github.com wrote:
I wanted it to be like this https://i.imgur.com/1BxkIkx.jpg, and I thought that's the default:
- image on left, see how the icon (list item) slides up under the title bar?
- image on right, see how the icon (list item) slides up from under the nav bar?
— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/spacecowboy/NotePad/issues/342.
No, on 5.1.1, the title bar scrolls up under the statusbar, while I expect it to be fixed and only the content to scroll under.
This is a common pattern found in material design apps. You can read about it here https://www.google.com/design/spec/patterns/scrolling-techniques.html#scrolling-techniques-scrolling
Now whether or not it is the best design choice for this app is a more subjective discussion :) But I think it's quite nice as it allows more content to be visible on the screen.
Flexible space with overlapping content :)
I find it unhelpful as I finish adding items or setting reminders that now I need to scroll up to be able to get the back arrow visible.
So you are referring to the Editor in particular then? And not the List?
Yes, sorry if I did not make that clear from the start.
Hmm, yeah I see your point in this case. Might change it and see how it feels.
Actually it appears to have 2 modes now (6.0beta5):
Oh, now I see it, on a tablet is clearer. You are using a card view, right? Any reason to prefer that instead of, say RecyclerView (with inneroverlay) ?
It's not a card view as implemented by Google. It's just backgrounds and stuff to make it look like a card. It was implemented before card view was available. Long term, I would really like to RecyclerView all the things.
The difference in scrolling behavior is likely due to CoordinatorLayout not responding to programmatic scrolling, which adding a reminder does.
I wanted it to be like this, and I thought that's the default: