spacemeshos / smapp-lite

The light wallet application for Spacemesh network
3 stars 2 forks source link

Improve Mnemonics Verification step #9

Open monikasmolarek opened 5 months ago

monikasmolarek commented 5 months ago

Please, place the missed words on their places appears all the time. I guess it should be displayed only when the verification was not successful - words put in the incorrect places.

And then this message should be more visible (orange?). After an incorrect placement, the user doesn’t know easily what’s wrong, only the "Next" button is disabled.

Also, I think all other words should be hidden for security reasons?

Screenshot 2024-05-22 at 22 39 30

Screenshot 2024-05-22 at 21 51 00

brusherru commented 4 months ago

Well, I can replace this screen with something simpler and not showing other words. Like 4 dropdowns next to random numbers:

2.   [ east         v ]
5.   [ south        v ]
12.  [ pick a word  v ]
17.  [ pick a word  v ]

But later, after all the mandatory things will be implemented :)

monikasmolarek commented 3 months ago

I actually think I was being ridiculous or too much focused on details. It's completely unnecessary to change the words presentation anyhow. The messages should be rendered conditionally and made more visible/distinct, but the grid with all the words is perfect. No need to waste time on it