search

sparkle-project / Sparkle

A software update framework for macOS
https://sparkle-project.org
Other
7.37k stars 1.05k forks source link

bundled executables don't have sandbox enabled #2599

Closed castdrian closed 1 month ago

castdrian commented 1 month ago

Summary

sparkle framework fails app store connect verification due to missing sandboxing for its bundled executables ishare-1721493866

I of course don't actually use sparkle in the app store build, but the framework is still bundled into the application

Possible Fix

enable the app sandbox for all bundled executables

Version

2.6.4

zorgiepoo commented 1 month ago

I of course don't actually use sparkle in the app store build, but the framework is still bundled into the application

Developers do not bundle Sparkle for App Store builds.

castdrian commented 1 month ago

Developers do indeed bundle Sparkle for App Store builds.

zorgiepoo commented 1 month ago

I'm half-certain your app will be rejected if you include Sparkle in your app even if you get past these issues. It's not advised and most if not all apps do not do it. Plus you are bundling a framework you don't need for an App Store build, so it's also a waste.

Sparkle has never been fully sandboxed and developers have been shipping App Store and Sparkle builds side-by-side since 2011 or whenever the App Store came out for macOS.