search

sparna-git / skos-testing-tool

A web UI to asses the quality of SKOS and SKOS-XL files. Frontend for qSKOS.
https://skos-play.sparna.fr/skos-testing-tool/
GNU Lesser General Public License v3.0
9 stars 1 forks source link

probleme pour detecter Hierarchical Redundancy #14

Open croussey opened 4 months ago

croussey commented 4 months ago

Bonjour dans mon fichier rdf plusieurs concept schemes sont declarés ainsi il est possible d'avoir aussi les liens broadMatch narrowMatch. des redundances hierarchiques entre concept appartenant à des concepts schemes differents sont detectés. sauf que la redundance hierarchique ne s'applique que sur les concepts d'un meme concept scheme, d'apres la doc https://github.com/cmader/qSKOS/wiki/Quality-Issues#hierarchical-redundancy

voir le gitlab institutionnel https://gitlab.irstea.fr/copain/phenologicalstages dans le repertoire grapevine le fichier grapevine_scales_latest.rdf le fichier owl est visible aussi sur agroportal https://agroportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PPD-GV

tfrancart commented 4 months ago

image

e.g. [ https://opendata.inrae.fr/ppd-res/grapevine#bbch_grapevine_secondaryStage_BBCH67 - https://opendata.inrae.fr/ppd-res/grapevine#bbch_grapevine_principalStage_BBCH6 ]

We have this in the file

<https://opendata.inrae.fr/ppd-res/grapevine#bbch_grapevine_secondaryStage_BBCH67> skos:broader <https://opendata.inrae.fr/ppd-res/grapevine#bbch_grapevine_principalStage_BBCH6> .
<https://opendata.inrae.fr/ppd-res/grapevine#bbch_grapevine_secondaryStage_BBCH67> skos:broadMatch <https://opendata.inrae.fr/ppd-res/grapevine#ifv_epicure_grapevine_secondaryStage_24> .
<https://opendata.inrae.fr/ppd-res/grapevine#ifv_epicure_grapevine_secondaryStage_24> skos:broadMatch <https://opendata.inrae.fr/ppd-res/grapevine#bbch_grapevine_principalStage_BBCH6> .

<https://opendata.inrae.fr/ppd-res/grapevine#bbch_grapevine_secondaryStage_BBCH67> skos:inScheme <https://opendata.inrae.fr/ppd-res/grapevine#bbch_individualScale_grapevine> .
<https://opendata.inrae.fr/ppd-res/grapevine#bbch_grapevine_secondaryStage_BBCH6> skos:inScheme <https://opendata.inrae.fr/ppd-res/grapevine#bbch_individualScale_grapevine> .
<https://opendata.inrae.fr/ppd-res/grapevine#ifv_epicure_grapevine_secondaryStage_24> skos:inScheme <https://opendata.inrae.fr/ppd-res/grapevine#ifv_epicure_scale_grapevine>

and indeed https://opendata.inrae.fr/ppd-res/grapevine#ifv_epicure_grapevine_secondaryStage_24 does not belong to the same scheme.

I think the practice is usually not to have multiple schemes in one files, hence the qSkos hierarchy builder does not check whether the concepts in the hierarchy actually belong to different schemes or not. This is on qSkos side, I can't do anything here.