Broadcast transaction from unknown wallet gives timeout error

sparrowwallet / sparrow

Desktop Bitcoin Wallet focused on security and privacy. Free and open source.

https://sparrowwallet.com/

Apache License 2.0

1.32k stars 188 forks source link

Broadcast transaction from unknown wallet gives timeout error #1468

Closed tadeubas closed 2 months ago

tadeubas commented 2 months ago

I did 3 tests to be sure:

The first was a wach-only wallet loaded on Sparrow that broadcast a transaction signed by an HW (Krux v24.07) without errors.
The second and third were a complete signed PSBT from a wallet unknown to Sparrow (not loaded) that were broadcasted with the error shown in the image below. I tried to broadcast again with the same error, I looked for the transaction on my node and it was already found as transmitted!

Side note: For the second and third tests I was unable to finalize the unsigned transaction for sign because the wallet was not loaded on Sparrow, but HW (Krux v24.07) was able to sign the transaction without any issues.

craigraw commented 2 months ago

This appears to be a problem with the server you are connected to, which is not notifying Sparrow that the transaction has been received in the node you are connected to.

Which wallet is loaded in Sparrow is unrelated.

tadeubas commented 2 months ago

Strange, but if it only happened on my end, I will close this issue, but before let me just ask why it is necessary to have a loaded wallet in order to finalize the transaction for signing? It would be nice to have the option to just open any unsigned PSBT from an unknown wallet on Sparrow to generate the BBQR or other QR codes right?

craigraw commented 2 months ago

It would be nice to have the option to just open any unsigned PSBT from an unknown wallet on Sparrow to generate the BBQR or other QR codes right?

Sparrow uses the signing wallet for many things in the signing process. You can use File menu to show the PSBT from an unknown wallet as a QR if you like though.

tadeubas commented 2 months ago

Wow I see, thx a lot ❤️ : File > Show PSBT as QR...