search

speed47 / dvdisaster

A tool providing additional ECC protection for optical media (unofficial version)
https://dvdisaster.jcea.es
GNU General Public License v3.0
261 stars 20 forks source link

Thanks #16

Open Floessie opened 3 years ago

Floessie commented 3 years ago

Salut Stéphane,

I just wanted to thank you for reviving dvdisaster. It's been an invaluable tool for me in the past and will sure be in the BD-R era.

I just realized it was dropped from Debian Testing for being unfit for GCC 10. Are you planning to point the maintainers to your repository so it will be part of Bullseye again? Is there any contact with Carsten Gnörlich or any info on why he abandoned dvdisaster without making sure someone else cares about the "official" branch?

Best, Flössie

speed47 commented 3 years ago

Hey Floessie, Thanks for your message.

I didn't realize dvdisaster was kicked out of Debian Testing, but you're right: https://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=957156 This "bug" is already fixed in my version. The patch is only a few lines long. I confirm it builds even under Debian Sid (just tried, to be sure). I'll try to push the patch to their bugtracker. As the maintainer already has TONS of custom patches for dvdisaster, hopefully (s)he'll not be against adding one more.

About the official author, he's aware of this repository, and is happy/okay with it. I think we can't say he abandoned the project, my guess is that it's mainly a life priority issue. He doesn't seem to have ruled out resuming work on it at a later time, so, only time will tell.

Floessie commented 3 years ago

@speed47

This "bug" is already fixed in my version. The patch is only a few lines long. I confirm it builds even under Debian Sid (just tried, to be sure). I'll try to push the patch to their bugtracker.

That's probably a good idea. You could also try to build it on Sid with the latest Clang. That often reveals more problems than GCC.

He doesn't seem to have ruled out resuming work on it at a later time, so, only time will tell.

Good to know, he's aware of your work. As dvdisaster.org is dead this would need a reboot anyway, so he could start again based on your work, I guess.

Thanks again for your efforts, Flössie

speed47 commented 3 years ago

For the record, dvdisaster is back in Bullseye https://packages.debian.org/bullseye/dvdisaster

r1bnc commented 3 years ago

I'm wondering whether you will still support this project in the near future. Just to make it work on newer OSes. I'm not sure on which to use, the debian repo version (with GUI) or this version (linux CLI only) or just use it on Windows 10 to create disc ecc, and possibly recover those disc when they are bit rotting after few years.

speed47 commented 3 years ago

Yes, I'm planning to continue supporting this version for the years to come, this is the very reason of the existence of this repo. I do have media protected by dvdisaster, so it's in my direct interest to ensure it still works in 10+ years.

Note that this version does have GUI too, you just have to compile it. It's easy to provide a precompiled CLI version that works everywhere (Debian, Centos, Arch, etc) but the GUI version must be compiled on the OS it'll be running on, or it won't work, due to the multiple dependencies. Compiling yourself might be easier than you think :)

In any case, I've learnt a bit about github actions in the last few weeks, so prepackaging a GUI version for several Debian, Ubuntu etc. versions might be doable. Will look into that in the next few days

r1bnc commented 3 years ago

For the linux version maybe an AppImage package is a way to go? One more thing, according to the manual:

Q 1.3: Is dvdisaster compatible with future releases?
Yes, dvdisaster files are intended for an archival time of many years. When upgrading to a
newer version of dvdisaster you can continue using images and error correction data created
from previous versions. There is no need to recreate them again.

does this still hold even on your version? If I create an ECC file for newer disc using the debian release of dvdisaster (0.79.5) and open them in your (0.79.6pt4) on windows (vice versa), are they still compatible?

Thanks

speed47 commented 3 years ago

AppImage might be a good idea indeed.

Yes, the compatibility does still hold with my version. To be clear, I'll never break compat with previous versions, this would be against the goal of this repo.

speed47 commented 3 years ago

I just released an AppImage version. Thanks for the idea!

cy7yz2rj commented 2 years ago

Just found out about this, great news.

Upon noticing the official dvdisaster site was down I feared an eventual removal from Debian, which would be unfortunate given the purpose of the program.

Thank you for reviving it and keeping backwards compatibility and also thank you Carsten Gnörlich if you're reading.

Yorizuka commented 1 year ago

I don't have a lot to say except for thank you for maintaining this, this software is still critical for some of us!