search

speed47 / dvdisaster

A tool providing additional ECC protection for optical media (unofficial version)
https://dvdisaster.jcea.es
GNU General Public License v3.0
259 stars 20 forks source link

macOS Build not Opening #85

Closed dejl closed 3 months ago

dejl commented 5 months ago

Hi

I have latest macOS Sonoma 14.3 (Apple M1) The macOS build doesn't open. I have also tried the CLionly build, same message

Screenshot 2024-02-02 at 6 07 55 pm

I have also tried launching the executable in the macOS folder of the .app, and the same message.

albertogarciacz commented 5 months ago

I have the same problem. Running on Sonoma 14.3 (M2 MAX).

vicmarto commented 4 months ago

Same here (Sonoma 14.3 on an INTEL mac).

speed47 commented 4 months ago

Hello,

Unfortunately I don't have a Mac, so I'm pretty blind about the MacOS build. The only thing I have is the automated regression tests on GitHub (which do pass successfully, so the binary does work correctly there), and I also use GitHub actions to build the Mac version and package it.

I suspect this might be an issue with the dmg packaging, as the binary does work in the regression tests launched by GitHub on a Mac, using macOS 12. Could one of you unpack the dmg file and try to launch the binary manually?

I see that GitHub now supports macOS 13 and 14 in beta, so I could also try to build under those, but I suspect/hope that an app built for macOS 12 is also supposed to work on a more recent version?

albertogarciacz commented 4 months ago

I mounted the dmg and then ran /Volumes/dvdisaster-v0.79.10-pl2-cli-only/dvdisaster.app/Contents/MacOS/dvdisaster from the command line. Unfortunately resulting in the same error message.

dejl commented 4 months ago

The latest release is the same as above as well

I cloned the repo and can get a working build from source without any fuss, though.

Screenshot 2024-02-22 at 11 40 39 pm
vwellum commented 3 months ago

When sht like this happens: sudo xattr -cr /Applications/dvdisaster.app usually fixes most of the things.

speed47 commented 3 months ago

When sht like this happens: sudo xattr -cr /Applications/dvdisaster.app usually fixes most of the things.

Oh, is that because macOS tags the file as being downloaded from Internet and somehow insecure, or something like that? If this fixes the problem, can somebody run xattr -lr /Applications/dvdisaster.app before, so that I can get an idea of which extended attributes are causing this behavior?

albertogarciacz commented 3 months ago

I've just run sudo xattr -c /Applications/dvdisaster.app and then the app and it seems to solve the problem described.

Screenshot 2024-03-11 at 17 04 11

Please find output of sudo xattr -l /Applications/dvdisaster.app that I had ran beforehand. 

com.apple.provenance:
0000   01 00 00 71 6A 30 22 ED C8 C3 53                   ...qj0"...S

com.apple.quarantine: 0183;65ef2a9f;Safari;1E4929C3-C9A7-461B-BE3F-4E5D8CB1E8FF
speed47 commented 3 months ago

Thanks a lot for the feedback. A lot of resources can be found online about this com.apple.quarantine attribute behavior, which seems to be set when a program is downloaded from anywhere except the Apple store. The error message is extremely misleading, I have no idea why they didn't go the "warning: this program has been downloaded from an unknown source, please run it only if you completely trust the source" instead, but, well, that's how it is.

I've added the information on the release page and referenced this issue. Thanks!