search

spicywebau / craft-neo

A Matrix-like field type for Craft CMS that uses existing fields
Other
403 stars 63 forks source link

New Neo blocks drop content until saved #894

Closed roelvanhintum closed 2 weeks ago

roelvanhintum commented 3 weeks ago

Bug Description

When creating a new Neo block on an entry, the content wont save the first time and is lost. The block itself is saved, but all fields in it are empty. We downgraded for now to 4.1.3, which fixes the problem.

Steps to reproduce

  1. Create a new Neo block on an entry
  2. Fill content fields
  3. Save
  4. Content fields are empty

Expected behaviour

Expected behavior would be content in fields within a new Neo block to be saved.

Neo version

4.2.2

Craft CMS version

4.10.0

What is the affected Neo field's propagation method?

all

Does this issue involve templating, and if so, is eager-loading used?

This is not a templating issue

ttempleton commented 3 weeks ago

I'm unable to reproduce this. In the past, content loss on save has tended to involve the Preparse Field plugin - are you using that plugin? If not, then are you able to reproduce the issue on a new Craft install?

roelvanhintum commented 3 weeks ago

No, but here is a complete list of the plugins we're using:

Cache control 1.0.8 // custom plugin, doesn't effect entries etc CKEditor 3.8.3 CP Field Inspect 1.4.4 Expanded Singles 2.0.5 Field Manager 3.0.8 fortrabbit Object Storage Volume 3.0.0 Hyper 1.1.31 ImageOptimize 4.0.8 Many to Many 3.0.4 Neo 4.1.3 Read-only Field 2.0.1 SendGrid 2.0.1 Sentry SDK 2.0.1 SEOmatic 4.0.50 Super Table 3.0.14

I'll get back on the clean install.

Mixxey commented 2 weeks ago

I am experiencing the same problem (only for new entries; adding content to an existing entry works fine). Here are my installation's specs:

PHP version 8.0.30 OS version Linux 6.5.0-35-generic Database driver & version MySQL 5.7.44 Image driver & version Imagick 3.7.0 (ImageMagick 6.9.10-23) Craft edition & version Craft Pro 4.10.0 Yii version 2.0.50 Twig version v3.8.0 Guzzle version 7.8.1

Asset Usage 3.3.0 Blitz 4.18.1 CKEditor 3.8.3 Cloudflare 2.1.0 CP Clear Cache 1.3.1 CP Field Inspect 1.4.4 Craft JWT Auth dev-develop-craft-4 Dumper 5.0.1 Elements Panel 2.0.0 Embedded Assets 4.1.0 Feed Me 5.5.0 Field Manager 3.0.8 Google Cloud Storage 2.2.0 ImageOptimize 4.0.8 Logs 4.0.1 Navigation 2.0.28 Neo 4.2.2 Remote Backup 4.1.6 Retour 4.1.16 Sentry SDK 3.0.0 SEOmatic 4.0.50 Smith 2.0.1 Wordsmith 4.4.0

Tim-Wils commented 2 weeks ago

Client of ours experienced the same problem. Only when creating new entries.

ttempleton commented 2 weeks ago

@roelvanhintum @Mixxey @Tim-Wils If possible, could one of you please post a screen recording showing the full process that leads to it? I'm still unable to reproduce this, so hopefully that helps me figure out what I'm missing.

Mixxey commented 2 weeks ago

Sorry for everything being in German 😅

Recorded Session - I hope the link works!

Here is what happens:

  1. I create a new entry.
  2. I add some content to a Neo block.
  3. I save the entry (Ctrl+S) -> Block is empty
  4. I create another block + save again -> Block is empty
  5. I create yet another block + save again -> Content of the block is saved

I hope this helps :)

ttempleton commented 2 weeks ago

Thanks @Mixxey - can confirm I have reproduced the issue after watching the recording.

ttempleton commented 2 weeks ago

I've just released 4.2.4 to fix this bug. Please let me know if the issue persists after updating, though.

ttempleton commented 1 week ago

@ayush000 that's fixed now in 5.0.4.