spinicist / QUIT

A set of tools for processing Quantitative MR Images
Mozilla Public License 2.0
58 stars 20 forks source link

'holes' in qmt output #33

Closed CarolynMcNabb closed 1 year ago

CarolynMcNabb commented 1 year ago

Dear @spinicist,

We've been using the quit qmt function to analyse some of our magnetisation transfer data from two different scanners (a Siemens Connectom and a Siemens Prisma). We're running into an issue whereby some voxels inside the brain are exhibiting incredibly small (but not zero) values (e.g. for the QMT_f_b image, all the dark voxels have the value 9.999999974752427e-7). These voxels are often within the white matter, so it's not a masking problem or anything like that. The number of iterations for these voxels is relatively low (below 10) so I don't think it's necessarily a convergence issue either - though I could be wrong. I've included an image below so you can see what I'm talking about. Importantly, the images that we are using as input do not have holes in these locations.

I'm running the command as follows:

${software_dir}/qi qmt --verbose ${qMT_dir}/${id}_qMT_merged_mcf_biascorrected.nii.gz --T1 ${qMT_dir}/${id}_D1_T1.nii.gz --mask ${qMT_dir}/${id}_maskResample_mcf.nii.gz --lineshape ${json_dir}/superlorentz.json --B1 ${qMT_dir}/${id}_POLY_B1.nii --f0 ${qMT_dir}/${id}_FM_f0.nii.gz --out ${qMT_dir}/${id}_ < ${json_dir}/WANDQMT_3TM.json

Any advice you have would be very much appreciated!

Kind regards, Carolyn McNabb

Screenshot from 2022-12-05 14-47-11

spinicist commented 1 year ago

Hello,

What do your input B1, f0 & T1 maps look like for this subject?

CarolynMcNabb commented 1 year ago

Thanks for your super quick response! B1 looks like this: Screenshot from 2022-12-05 15-40-59

f0 like this: Screenshot from 2022-12-05 15-41-04

and T1 like this: Screenshot from 2022-12-05 15-41-08

spinicist commented 1 year ago

Okay, those all look reasonable. Are you able to share the full dataset via Dropbox or similar (you can direct it to my work e-mail)?

CarolynMcNabb commented 1 year ago

Thanks @spinicist - I've created a OneDrive folder and shared it with your work email address.

spinicist commented 1 year ago

This was discussed via e-mail and is not a problem with QUIT, so closing the issue here.