splunk / qbec

configure kubernetes objects on multiple clusters using jsonnet
https://qbec.io
Apache License 2.0
168 stars 37 forks source link

why does expandHelmTemplate deprecated #286

Open vm86 opened 1 year ago

vm86 commented 1 year ago

Hi! I found deprecated warning in docs. https://github.com/splunk/qbec/blame/main/site/content/reference/jsonnet-native-funcs.md#L10

The commit was created about two years ago.

Why was this function stayed deprecated? It is very convenient to use. I suggest to delete this deprecated warning and continue to support this function.

Andor commented 1 year ago

As additional point: if ever #265 helm datasource will be implemented, datasources exists only for qbec, not for jsonnet-qbec. So some of the functionality of the jsonnet-qbec will be lost.

gotwarlost commented 1 year ago

the only problem is one of maintaining this function that was written for helm2 and make sure it still works for helm3. I'm ok leaving it in if that is what people want.

Andor commented 1 year ago

function that was written for helm2 and make sure it still works for helm3

We tested it with helm3 and it just works. Documentation need to be updated tho because some options (name) from helm2 doesn't exists for helm3.

Also, could you please take a look at Tanka's implementation of helm integration, maybe you will find it a bit more handy: https://tanka.dev/helm and https://github.com/grafana/jsonnet-libs/blob/master/tanka-util/helm.libsonnet

Andor commented 9 months ago

So, for example, this code just works:

local argocd = std.native('expandHelmTemplate') (
  'https://github.com/argoproj/argo-helm/releases/download/argo-cd-5.51.4/argo-cd-5.51.4.tgz',
  params.values,
  {
    namespace: params.namespace,
    nameTemplate: 'argocd',
    thisFile: std.thisFile,  // important
  },
);