srophe / manuscripts

Repository for Syriac Manuscript Projects
7 stars 4 forks source link

MS-28 #21

Open jarnwine opened 10 years ago

jarnwine commented 10 years ago

Is reference to Caesaria to a person or place? https://github.com/srophe/manuscripts/blob/Justin-editing-february/28.xml#L226 https://github.com/srophe/manuscripts/blob/Justin-editing-february/28.xml#L318

Is this msItem all right without a locus, since Wright does not mention it? https://github.com/srophe/manuscripts/blob/Justin-editing-february/28.xml#L231

Have these msItems been formulated correctly, i.e. should they be subsets "c" within this larger "b" category? https://github.com/srophe/manuscripts/blob/Justin-editing-february/28.xml#L224-L232

Need to wrap the in this quote, but my computer lacks the Syriac font. Please help! https://github.com/srophe/manuscripts/blob/Justin-editing-february/28.xml#L523

tuckerdhannah commented 10 years ago

Hey Justin,

I assume Caesaria to be a place.

Would need to see Wright's version to determine the locus question. Obviously if there just isn't one then we have to do without it, but if any sort of range is implied we should include it to the maximum specificity attainable.

The two c-level items seems correct to me as I read it on the link. Not sure if Wright left it unclear, but from what I can tell this organization seems correct.

Next time I'm editing I'll take a look at applying the in that quote if someone else hasn't gotten it already.

On Mon, Mar 17, 2014 at 12:37 PM, jarnwine notifications@github.com wrote:

Is reference to Caesaria to a person or place?

https://github.com/srophe/manuscripts/blob/Justin-editing-february/28.xml#L226

https://github.com/srophe/manuscripts/blob/Justin-editing-february/28.xml#L318

Is this msItem all right without a locus, since Wright does not mention it?

https://github.com/srophe/manuscripts/blob/Justin-editing-february/28.xml#L231

Have these msItems been formulated correctly, i.e. should they be subsets "c" within this larger "b" category?

https://github.com/srophe/manuscripts/blob/Justin-editing-february/28.xml#L224-L232

Need to wrap the in this quote, but my computer lacks the Syriac font. Please help!

https://github.com/srophe/manuscripts/blob/Justin-editing-february/28.xml#L523

Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/srophe/manuscripts/issues/21 .

Tucker Hannah MBA Class of 2015, Finance and Strategy Owen Graduate School of Management at Vanderbilt University Email: Tucker.Hannah@owen.vanderbilt.edu Cell: 615-305-6075 www.linkedin.com/in/tuckerdhannah

davidamichelson commented 10 years ago

Thanks all, a couple of procedural notes. Justin, perhaps split these into separate issues and describe them in the title. Also, Tucker, do note that if you use an e-mail signature it goes into the github issue tracker unless you delete it.

davidamichelson commented 10 years ago

Justin please move the two extracts to the b-level and add locus based on Foll. 52b-53

davidamichelson commented 10 years ago

@jarnwine Please close this issue after making the changes.