Default modules and hiding Prelude

[melrief]

Currently Hawk exposes some modules independently by what the user set on its configuration file (Prelude.hs). This is due to the fact that I considered those modules essential for any Haskell application. What do you think, we should keep them always loaded? The list of modules is in Config.hs, I report it here

"System.Console.Hawk.Representable"
"GHC.Num"
"GHC.Real"
"GHC.Types"
"Data.ByteString.Lazy.Char8"
"Data.Bool"
"Data.Char"
"Data.Either"
"Data.Eq"
"Data.Function"
"Data.Int"
"Data.Maybe"
"Data.Ord"

note that currently Hawk exposes Prelude with the qualification P, so if we want to have True instead of P.True we must import Data.Bool. Same for almost all the others modules. That's why I think we should keep them automatically imported. Maybe we could, in future, give an option to the user to avoid automatic loading of default modules.

The exceptions are System.Console.Hawk.Representable, that is automatically imported because Hawk cannot work without it, and Data.ByteString.Lazy.Char8 that is imported because Hawk works on (lazy) ByteStrings. Now, for the first module we can't do much, it must be loaded by default. For ByteString I don't know, if we load it in this way then many functions that are usually related to lists will be for the ByteString type. This can be misleading:

hawk -e "take 2 [1,2]"

Won't compile:
    Couldn't match expected type `Data.ByteString.Lazy.Internal.ByteString'
            with actual type `[t0]'

For me:

• keep Prelude with qualification P. If the user wants it exposed without qualification he can set it in Prelude.hs
• System.Console.Hawk.Representable, GHC.Num, GHC.Real, GHC.Types, Data.Bool, Data.Char, Data.Either, Data.Eq, Data.Function, Data.Int, Data.Maybe and Data.Ord should be imported by default, not matter what Prelude.hs contains. I don't know if this list of modules is enough or I missed something.
• Data.ByteString.Lazy.Char8 should not be imported by default. The user must import it in Prelude.hs. In this way if he wants List exposed without qualification he can do that. The default Prelude.hs should import it with qualification BS

[gelisam]

Personally, I probably populate Prelude.hs with all those imports, including import qualified Prelude as P, so that we start with sane default yet defer absolute authority to the user. But I don't feel very strongly about the issue.

[melrief]

For me it is more about how clean is the user configuration in Prelude.hs: if the user must import every single import (because Prelude will be hiddend by default) then Prelude.hs will be full of lines importing every standard type of the Haskell standard library.

If we want to let the user decide everything, even that, what do you think about creating a module called Default which exports all those modules? Like

module System.Console.Hawk.Config.Modules.Defaults (
    module System.Console.Hawk.Representable,
    module GHC.Num,
    module GHC.Real,
    module GHC.Types,
    module Data.ByteString.Lazy.Char8,
    module Data.Bool,
    module Data.Char,
    module Data.Either,
    module Data.Eq,
    module Data.Function,
    module Data.Int,
    module Data.Maybe,
    module Data.Ord
    ) where

import System.Console.Hawk.Representable
import GHC.Num
import GHC.Real
import GHC.Types
import Data.ByteString.Lazy.Char8
import Data.Bool
import Data.Char
import Data.Either
import Data.Eq
import Data.Function
import Data.Int
import Data.Maybe
import Data.Ord

the user can decide if he wants to import it or not. But he doesn't have to import every module line by line, he can just import our defaults modules. So a good Prelude.hs will be:

import System.Console.Hawk.Config.Modules.Defaults
import Control.Monad
import qualified Prelude as P

[gelisam]

I don't mind either way. Your choice!

– Samuel

On 2013-08-11, at 9:45 AM, Mario Pastorelli notifications@github.com wrote:

For me it is more about how clean is the user configuration in Prelude.hs: if the user must import every single import (because Prelude will be hiddend by default) then Prelude.hs will be full of lines importing every standard type of the Haskell standard library.

If we want to let the user decide everything, even that, what do you think about creating a module called Default which exports all those modules? Like

module System.Console.Hawk.Config.Modules.Defaults ( module System.Console.Hawk.Representable, module GHC.Num, module GHC.Real, module GHC.Types, module Data.ByteString.Lazy.Char8, module Data.Bool, module Data.Char, module Data.Either, module Data.Eq, module Data.Function, module Data.Int, module Data.Maybe, module Data.Ord ) where

import System.Console.Hawk.Representable import GHC.Num import GHC.Real import GHC.Types import Data.ByteString.Lazy.Char8 import Data.Bool import Data.Char import Data.Either import Data.Eq import Data.Function import Data.Int import Data.Maybe import Data.Ord the user can decide if he wants to import it or not. But he doesn't have to import every module line by line, he can just import our defaults modules. So a good Prelude.hs will be:

import System.Console.Hawk.Config.Modules.Defaults import Control.Monad import qualified Prelude as P — Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub.