Closed fiatexodus closed 5 years ago
I'm not terribly familiar with Product Hunt's scoring methodology.
Tagging @GinaAbrams to bring her into this discussion as well.
hey @AC-FTW thanks for the ping on this, we're working on an update and will share very soon. It's top of mind and receiving attention. 🙏
Hey @AC-FTW we've removed the internal team score and are only using credible product hunt votes. Link to forum post here. I am going to close this issue soon unless there are further questions. 🙏
In my recent forum post on February App Mining, @pstan26 said:
in response to this issue we raised with Product Hunt's team scoring:
I've created this issue (which relates to the earlier issue #3) to formally propose that we retain the Product Hunt Community score because it is transparent, but drop the Product Hunt Team Score from consideration in App Mining Rewards until the following two conditions are met:
I believe these suggestions will deliver more value to both Blockstack and App developers by helping to improve Apps as a result of Product Hunt's reviews instead of making the situation somewhat of a mystery as it stands today.
I also believe condition number 2 above might get tricky--when there are 400 apps and 200 of them are not in development, maybe it doesn't make sense to review all of them, maybe just the first 200. However even reviewing 200 apps wouldn't scale well. Here are some solutions I can think of to this issue that might make sense:
@pstan26 @larrysalibra @jeffdomke @hstove and @friedger what do you think?
Also @pstan26, what time-frame would be reasonable for such a change to occur if we decided to go ahead with it?