stacksgov / sips

Community-submitted Stacks Improvement Proposals (SIPs)
132 stars 80 forks source link

sBTC has token ticker collisions, should it be changed? #116

Open 314159265359879 opened 1 year ago

314159265359879 commented 1 year ago

image

There are at least four other tokens with the same ticker. Should a different ticker be used?

Hero-Gamer commented 1 year ago

(without having digging into what others are exactly, so pls take my comment with a grain of salt)

badonyx commented 1 year ago

Yes it should be changed, but not for this reason.

https://twitter.com/0xbabo/status/1623004605713096705

I still don't like "sBTC" as the name for Stacks' native BTC. It's inconsistent with established branding around the letter 'X' (STX, PoX, ALEX, xBTC, xUSD). And it's just begging to be nicknamed "shitcoin-BTC" by BTC purists.

I always liked the ticker "xBTC" but never liked the instrument and I don't think anyone will want to use it after sBTC. So there's no reason not to co-opt the ticker other than to avoid collisions. Existing asset tickers xBTC and xUSD would need to be rebranded to avoid confusion but I don't think this would be particularly difficult considering the limited reach of these assets (basically contained entirely within the ALEX and Arkadiko ecosystems).

cuevasm commented 1 year ago

Anyone that feels strongly about this/naming in general should get involved in the brand WG: https://github.com/stacks-network/stacks/discussions/483