remyroy
commented
1 year ago I think it's a good idea to bring back the choice to use 0x00 or 0x01 withdraw credentials. I agree that the default option should be the option that offers the 0x01 withdraw credentials with a withdrawal address.
We'll work on this.
Issue
Recently #153 updated the path for users to be forced to provide a withdrawal address. This change was in anticipation of changes coming to the
staking-deposit-clitool where a PR was up to make this required, but I may have jumped the gun a bit.After more discussion, concerns have been raised regarding removing the option for users to opt-out of receiving automatic withdrawals. This could be desired for various reasons, and more importantly it's probably not best to remove this option when UX could be used to offer both.
I can put up a PR to revert the previous changes, which removed the toggle for "Use Advanced Inputs" and simply made the field required.
Beyond that reversion, I wanted to open this issue for discussion if folks had any input on improving the UX here for users.
I think it would be nice to see the address input visible by default, and change the toggle to some form of "opt-out" input, perhaps reusing the toggle or maybe a checkbox. I think the majority of users are going to prefer having excess balance delivered automatically, and we should accommodate that to make that the default flow, while still providing an easy clear way to disable.