search

stalwartlabs / mail-server

Secure & Modern All-in-One Mail Server (IMAP, JMAP, POP3, SMTP)
https://stalw.art
4.79k stars 193 forks source link

[enhancement]: Manage untrusted sieve from web client #515

Open Megver83 opened 3 months ago

Megver83 commented 3 months ago

Which feature or improvement would you like to request?

I'd like to see this feature: just like admins can manage global and trusted sieve scripts from the web client, users could do the same from the self-service portal to manage their own ("untrusted") scripts. An interface like Roundcube's Managesieve plugin would make it easier for all users, since it's user-friendly and also has the option to directly write the scripts.

Is your feature request related to a problem?

Managing sieve in a user-friendly way it's a PITA, e.g. Roundcube's solution is pretty good but I don't want to install a whole webmail just for this. There are more (third-party) alternatives, but if Stalwart could include one untrusted scripts, that would be awesome.

Code of Conduct

ruohki commented 3 months ago

I second this, i cannot find a working sieve client that lets me connect this is major pain in my bumbum

mightyBroccoli commented 3 months ago

@ruohki maybe have a look here http://sieve.info/

ruohki commented 3 months ago

@ruohki maybe have a look here http://sieve.info/

None of which work for me using a Windows pc without intensive fiddling.

alexmbird commented 3 months ago

Same here - when I try the managesieve CLI tool it claims to connect but I never get a prompt. There aren't any native OSX apps and the Thunderbird extension stopped working years ago.

Even a trivial form in the web UI that lets a user add a single, untrusted script would be a big improvement.

Megver83 commented 3 months ago

Fyi, there's sieve-connect which is a great CLI client for ManageSieve. You can view/edit/upload/check your sieve scripts to your server. But first, #548 needs to be solved.

alexmbird commented 3 months ago

@Megver83 thanks for the pointer.

Sieve-connect can at least connect, but right now it has some zany behaviour. Uploads claiming to fail, then the list command flaps between returning either no scripts or several prior "failed" uploads. I see @mdecimus has already committed a fix (thanks!) - will try this again when it gets into a release.

alexmbird commented 2 months ago

For 0.83+ the bug is fixed and sieve-connect now works. Bit clunky but then how often do you need to edit your ruleset.

X-Ryl669 commented 2 months ago

How did you get any client to connect? On my setup, managesieve server only support OAUTHBEARER authentication method, and none of the client I've tried support this authentication method.

I wonder why all of the other protocols support plain login but ManageSieve doesn't ?

alexmbird commented 2 months ago

@X-Ryl669 just sieve-connect -u <myusername> --notlsverify. That's on Debian with sieve-connect 0.90. The --notlsverify is because it defaults to connecting to localhost and the cert won't match.