stared / quantum-game

Quantum Game (old version) - a puzzle game with real quantum mechanics in a browser
http://v2016.quantumgame.io/
MIT License
341 stars 40 forks source link

Add some introductory material #12

Open emdash opened 6 years ago

emdash commented 6 years ago

I puzzled my way through 34 levels without really understanding what I was doing. The grid layout, and the straight-forward physics of mirrors constrain your choices enough that you can kindof just brute force through various permutations of things. It would be nice to have a bit more background in what this game models. Also, while the game is fun, it's not clear exactly how this relates to building quantum computers.

sbliven commented 6 years ago

I agree. The mouse-over explanations for each object feel more like reminders than proper explanations, and some are frustratingly vague (e.g. Faraday rotators have "different symmetries from sugar" but how?). I would have appreciated some static diagrams showing how each element modifies the phase, polarization, and entanglement of its inputs. I personally would have appreciated some math as well (not necessarily unitary transformations and linear algebra, but maybe just some basic notation for how the state changes). Maybe the introductory material could be in the form of some additional help pages rather than interrupting the game flow.

stared commented 6 years ago

@emdash @sbliven I agree it's needed, or at least - would be very beneficial. I even spend a day at one physics laboratory to take shots of various optical elements to show how do they look in real life.

Also, I am aware that more description would solve some confusion: https://github.com/stared/quantum-game/issues/10.

The original idea was to give:

What blocks me is time & energy (essentially I can't work on anything alone, sadly) + there would be some initial work to rewrite help in some framework. Now it is kind of hard to edit/add.

Some parts with links are in Quantum mechanics for high-school students on my blog.

sbliven commented 6 years ago

Reading #10 was the first time I heard about the encyclopedia. That already goes a long way to addressing my comments above. Then I noticed that clicking the mouse-over explanations also gets one to the encyclopedia. So maybe I'm just unobservant.

lurch commented 6 years ago

I know very little about quantum mechanics (so I'm also 'stumbling around' while trying to play the game), but is there any info on how to interpret the grid-patterns in the encyclopedia, i.e. what the different colours mean etc. ?

P.S. You were featured in this month's Linux Format magazine (issue 238) in the "HotPicks" section :grinning:

stared commented 6 years ago

@lurch Colours mean phase of a complex number, video http://nbviewer.jupyter.org/github/empet/Math/blob/master/DomainColoring.ipynb.

This whole encyclopedia needs a rewrite.

Ad Linux Format - thanks for letting me know! By any chance could you send me a photo of this page? :) (I cannot find option to buy PDF.)