status-im / status-desktop

Status Desktop client made in Nim & QML
https://status.app
Mozilla Public License 2.0
288 stars 78 forks source link

Settings -> Keycard: Copy of keycard settings could be improved #10647

Closed guylouis closed 1 month ago

guylouis commented 1 year ago

using 0.11.1

here's our current copy for keycard settings https://www.figma.com/file/idUoxN7OIW2Jpp3PMJ1Rl8/%E2%9A%99%EF%B8%8F-Settings-%7C-Desktop?type=design&node-id=199%3A2653&t=OJFATDkeg77doQal-1 image

for new users, these different wordings create significant cognitive load to understand.

here's a suggestion for your review of a simpler copy @xAlisher @benjthayer

Migrate an existing account to a new keycard Create a new keycard account Generate mnemonic words Import mnemonic words From an existing keycard Other Check what’s on a keycard Factory reset a keycard


@saledjenic please do not implement before review and confirmation from @benjthayer & @xAlisher

alaibe commented 1 year ago

@benjthayer any update on that one?

benjthayer commented 1 year ago

Hey @alaibe we will be putting in effort to optimise the usability of the Keycard flows when we look at them for mobile so we were thinking then would be a good time to review the copy here.

A couple of thoughts on the proposed copy in the meantime:

I'd need a bit of dedicated time to look at the rewording so may need to look at prioritisation with @John-44

saledjenic commented 1 year ago

Just want to mention one other aspect we've discussed which @guylouis pointed out during that meeting. There are some flows where we're considering the keycard as an empty keycard if it has no metadata even it has seed phrase stored and in such cases we just don't let user to proceed further. I don't know by heart what are those flows and we surely need to review them all what @guylouis will do after 0.13.0 release.

Some examples we've discussed then:

Though I am not sure for the last case that we should allow user to make a copy of a Keycard without metadata, even that's kinda expected by the keycard team, cause that ruins the design. How would this look if we would allow keycards without metadata (somehow incomplete)?

a3