stfwi / redstonepen

Minecraft mod adding a pen to draw Redstone tracks in all directions, a PLC for Redstone, and relays.
MIT License
14 stars 2 forks source link

[Feature Request] Invisible Redstone Dust #7

Closed rabrunos closed 2 years ago

rabrunos commented 2 years ago

Invisible Redstone Dust

This idea would make your mod unique and with an exclusive option, at least I didn't find it anywhere.

It would be something like what you find in this mod: SecretRoomsMod

This mod add some blocks that copy the texture of the block next to them, so these blocks are camouflaged and can have secret passages, secret chests, etc. But if you wear special glasses, you can see which blocks are camouflaged. minecraft

In the case of redstone, instead of camouflaging itself, it would just not appear. It would be as if the dust didn't have a texture, but when using the special glasses, the texture would appear highlighted so that the player could see which redstone dusts are invisible and which are not. And you could fill the ceiling or wall of your house with redstone dust but no one would see them. (Unless he had the glasses.)

stfwi commented 2 years ago

Hi, definitely a cool idea. I need to think about it - the thing with Hidden Rooms is that something is shown, so people e.g. know that they cannot place something at the block location (where the walk-through-stone is in your screenshots). I have seen already quite a few problems however where blocks were that you could not see, e.g. placing did not work for no obvious reasons to the players. Or the hidden blocks were replaced and their functionalities were broken. Mostly these problematic blocks were invisible light emitting blocks, but I can imagine with invisible redstone the same problems could arise. Let's think again about the scenarios.

rabrunos commented 2 years ago

I use Google Translate to translate the text, as I speak Portuguese! But I think I understood some of what you said.

So, if that's what I understand, to get around this problem of not seeing where the invisible Redstone Dusts are, I had this idea:

That way, the player would know when they have an Invisible Redstone Dusts in front of them, so they wouldn't accidentally break the block. And if the player has a Special Redstone Glasses, he would be able to see all the Invisible Redstone Dusts, even the ones that are far away from him.

I think that would solve most of the problem. (If that's what you said. As I said, I use Google Translate, and I answered based on what I understood.)

stfwi commented 2 years ago

Ok, thought about it now a few times - I think I like the mod to stay close to vanilla, means the dust should be visible. There are already quite a few mods out there providing wireless RS etc, I guess these will be used in favour of invisible dust (it's a feature that would have to be maintained for all the coming MC versions, it's probably not used enough for that). So, let's close this FR. Cheers,-