search

stoically / temporary-containers

Firefox Add-on that lets you open automatically managed disposable containers
https://addons.mozilla.org/firefox/addon/temporary-containers/
MIT License
846 stars 57 forks source link

Urgent: Seeking New Developers and Maintainers #634

Open electriquo opened 9 months ago

electriquo commented 9 months ago

Dear Temporary Containers Community,

It is with great sadness that the developer and the maintainer of the project, @stoically, passed away.

The Temporary Containers extension has been an invaluable tool for many users, providing enhanced privacy and security while browsing the web. In light of the recent events, we are reaching out to the community to discuss the future of the project and find a suitable individual or group to take over its maintenance.

If you are interested in contributing to the continued development of Temporary Containers or know someone who might be a good fit for this role, please join the discussion here. I believe that by coming together as a community, we can ensure the longevity and improvement of this essential tool.

Your input and involvement in this process are crucial for the future of Temporary Containers. Let's work together to ensure that this valuable resource continues to thrive.

Thank you for your support.

Gitoffthelawn commented 9 months ago

Thank you for posting this.

I am willing to help, but alas, my available time is currently limited. As such, I can see my role limited to:

  1. Management.
  2. Planning.
  3. Ensuring that the code remain free of malware/spyware.
  4. UI/UX design.
  5. UI/UX top layer coding, including HTML and CSS code.
  6. Bug reporting as I encounter issues.

What I, unfortunately, do not have sufficient time to do right now:

  1. JavaScript coding.
  2. Cross-platform and cross-browser testing.
  3. Answering many questions from users.
electriquo commented 9 months ago

@Gitoffthelawn Thank you. The call for a developer holds. We need a developer who can

dalto8 commented 7 months ago

Is there a list of priority issues anywhere that urgently need addressing?

I don't have the bandwidth to take over the entirety of the maintenance, but I would be willing to pitch in fix issues and contribute.

Also, does anyone have rights to merge code here or do we need to create a new fork?

electriquo commented 7 months ago

@dalto8

Is there a list of priority issues anywhere that urgently need addressing?

No, nothing has been constructed since no one has admin/triage/maintain access in this repository. Yet, I say that the fist thing we should do is to refresh the code by updating all dependencies/frameworks to the latest version. Is this this something you can do?

does anyone have rights to merge code here or do we need to create a new fork?

Not that we know of. We've probably need to create a fork.

tokariu commented 6 months ago

it's 2024 and it's just now that I noticed the addon isn't working as expected anymore (like, domain exceptions not working anymore). it's the reason I looked up the addon status and it's shocking to read that the dev has passed away. my deep condolences to all the affected people.

I'm unfortunately unable to offer ressources to get this addon working again. But I want to emphasize that this addon is indeed invaluable for modern privacy oriented browsing. I hope this thread gets more attention to find new people willing to contribute to this addon. it took more than a year for me to notice the problem, there are probably many more not yet knowing what's going on.

MurzNN commented 6 months ago

As an alternative or a potential successor, I can recommend this extension: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/containers-on-the-go/

crssi commented 6 months ago

As an alternative or a potential successor, I can recommend this extension: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/containers-on-the-go/

Why... nothing wrong with TemporaryContainers at the moment, and there is no extension getting even remotely close to this one.

MurzNN commented 6 months ago

As an alternative or a potential successor, I can recommend this extension: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/containers-on-the-go/

Why... nothing wrong with TemporaryContainers at the moment, and there is no extension getting even remotely close to this one.

I totally agree with this, the Temporary Containers is the best!! But if it one day stops working for new versions of Firefox for some reason, and we will not have ways to fix this, we should have alternatives.

And probably it will be easier to port some cool features of the Temporary Containers to another addon, that is in active development, than trying to resume development of this extension, without actual write access to the main repo. Personally, I'm not happy with this way and prefer to reborn the Temporary Containers brand, but we should keep it in mind as an alternative.

Gitoffthelawn commented 5 months ago

I totally agree with this, the Temporary Containers is the best!! But if it one day stops working for new versions of Firefox for some reason, and we will not have ways to fix this, we should have alternatives.

And probably it will be easier to port some cool features of the Temporary Containers to another addon, that is in active development, than trying to resume development of this extension, without actual write access to the main repo. Personally, I'm not happy with this way and prefer to reborn the Temporary Containers brand, but we should keep it in mind as an alternative.

I'm not sure Containers on the Go is in active development. It's last update was in 2019, and it currently only has 300-400 telemetry-enabled installations. That said, the xpi is less than 11Kb in size (which includes icons), so it does not have much code to maintain.

anewuser commented 5 months ago

I recommend this new lightweight extension to people who just want to be able to use disposable private tabs: https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/open-in-temp-container/

You need to go to the Firefox Add-ons Manager to see its options and make the toolbar button open new tabs. You can also give it permission to access your browsing history to prevent new URLs from being stored.

filex100 commented 5 months ago

Is it possible to send an advertisement through the add-on?

Even if it's a minor update, but maybe that would help.

I recommend this new lightweight extension to people who just want to be able to use disposable private tabs: https://addons.mozilla.org/addon/open-in-temp-container/

You need to go to the Firefox Add-ons Manager to see its options and make the toolbar button open new tabs. You can also give it permission to access your browsing history to prevent new URLs from being stored.

It doesn't look as comfortable as this one does.

If there is no alternative, maybe I won't use something similar and use other tools.

electriquo commented 5 months ago

Is it possible to send an advertisement through the add-on?

Regardless whether this is a good thing to do, no one has the permissions to merge changes. A fork is a must.

jonoff commented 3 months ago

Is it possible to send an advertisement through the add-on?

Regardless whether this is a good thing to do, no one has the permissions to merge changes. A fork is a must.

A contributor could get around the need to fork as stated in this comment, and enacted the deceased user policy to transfer ownership

boredsquirrel commented 1 month ago

https://github.com/igorlogius/open-in-temp-container

This is the source code of the addon that is still in development. I already had a crash but otherwise it seems to have potential.

the code is very short and understandable.

the addon seems to delete the containers a minute after closing.