Unclear description of indoor quest

[rhhsm]

I was asked "Is this within a building (OMV Petrol Station)?" about this node https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/10754518430 The node contains a emergency=defibrillator tag so I assume the quest is about the defibrillator. I think this is not very good tagging practice (opinions welcome), but I think SC is also in need of improvement by stating more clearly what the quest is about.

Expected Behavior I think the question should be "Is this defibrillator within a building?" or "Is this within a building (defibrillator)?"

Versions affected v56.0 10

[matkoniecz]

I think in this case it falls under "broken OSM data results in SC behaving weirdly"

I opened https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/4078362

[rhhsm]

I think there could be good reasons to include the emergency=defibrillator in the node for the amenity. However, how to tag when you know there's a defibrillator in a certain place, but you don't know where, should be discussed elsewhere (in the Community Forum, I guess) so that the wiki can be updated with a recommendation. Edit: this discussion is about this topic, in German though https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/emergency-defibrillator/79692/8

However, I think it's also worth looking at why it "results in SC behaving weirdly", i.e. how did info on amenity=fuel and name/operator/brand=OMV end up in the question and emergency=defibrillator not, and if something can be improved here

[westnordost]

Well, IF that amenity has a defi but should be mapped as a property on the amenity rather than as an own feature, defibrillator=yes (if it existed) or similar would need to be used. (Like bin=yes on bus stops)

[westnordost]

However, I think it's also worth looking at why it "results in SC behaving weirdly", i.e. how did info on amenity=fuel and name/operator/brand=OMV end up in the question and emergency=defibrillator not, and if something can be improved here

IIRC the osmfeatures library indeed returns a list of features that match a given set of tags. However, StreetComplete always only takes the first, IIRC the returned features are also ordered in a way that makes sense, so the first one is the "most likely" one. As to why not display all the features returned: Wouldn't make sense, would only lead to more confusion. It only makes sense to treat one object = one feature. Many questions wouldn't make sense when asked for a combination of multiple features - "Is this tankstation / defibrillator in-doors?" for starters

[rhhsm]

Thanks for looking it up. I guess it's not worth the effort to make the feature selection smarter. I revived the https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/emergency-defibrillator/79692/8 discussion and gave you credit for suggesting to add defibrillator=yes