rugk
commented
6 years ago Wow, thanks! You already did nearly all the research. And, BTW, the general idea LGTM.
I think "local" might refer to local museums, who show stuff of the region, e.g. tradition (i.e. if you speak German: Brauchtum). (Also, one may edit the wiki to clarify that.) Of course it is hard to find a picture for that.
For others some things I've noticed by looking at taginfo/your pictures:
- The "open_air" is kinda strange, as it does not really describe the type of the museum, i.e. what it shows, but just the "outer appearance". I mean a museum can be about anything of the other categories and still show that such a tag was used two times. And considering that bee thing it would not be bad. So use a more general one just showing plants/animals/…
- the picture for nature can be confused with something special as a musuem for dinosaurs. Note that taginfo even shows
- a "famous" (10 times used – wow the tag is generally used quite rarely) missing value, not documented in the OSM wiki, is "living_history". Makes sense, IMHO, but is likely also a mixture of "open air" and (usually) history
- "children" and "military" are missing
- as for a picture for history: Either use a picture of a famous event (like the storming of the Bastille), but that is hard to make in an international way, or just a general picture depicting time or so, or an old car or so
- also for the implementation maybe make sure the pictures for "arts" and "gallery" are not too far away. I understand why there are two tags (arts can be anything and specifying this as gallery makes sense IMHO, as galleries are a common type of museum and one may even separate them from the museum genre at all), but users are otherwise likely to accidentally choose "arts" before they notice there exists a "gallery" picture.
- whoever decided to name the bee value "apis mellifera" was kinda crazy… sorry, but what if I now make a . In the UI just name it "bee" if you really want to include it. (At least it is a quite value for that tag – strangely)
ServusWorld
westnordost
Codain
matkoniecz
General
Affected key(s) (or tags) to be modified: museum Question asked: What type of museum is XY?
Checklist
Checklist for quest suggestions (see guidelines):
Quantity
Although it sounds to be a very specific quest, it'd still show up frequently in cities. I can't compute the total number of quested objects all over europe, but maybe figures from a few cities are representative:
Moreover, I think the quest could be implemented easily using the quest generator.
Ideas for implementation
Element selection:
[tourism=museum][!museum]Proposed GUI: a simple image selection quest
railwayartapis_mellifera(I think it's strange that a own tag exists for that but maybe that's because bee death is an important topic at the moment)historyopen_airsciencegallerytechnologylocalnaturetransport