search

strongbox-password-safe / Strongbox

A KeePass/Password Safe Client for iOS and OS X
https://strongboxsafe.com
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
1.29k stars 100 forks source link

Cannot click on suggested item in Safari autofill popup #695

Closed Kugelfang666 closed 11 months ago

Kugelfang666 commented 1 year ago

This seems to be similar to the bug mentioned here: https://github.com/strongbox-password-safe/Strongbox/issues/502

Environment: MacOS 13.3.1 Safari: 16.4 Strongbox: 1.58.13

Case 1: The autofill popup suggested a matching item in my database: I'm able to operate the popup with my mouse. This means that the item gets highlighted on mouseover etc. However, I cannot click on an item neither with the mouse nor with 'enter' on my keyboard to trigger the unlock process. A restart of Sarfari or the full Mac did not help. I disabled and re-enabled autofill with no effect.

Case 2: The autofill popup does NOT show me a match. I click on 'Strongbox' and unlock. in the search menu I can find the right item select it and the User + PW gets autofilled into the correct fields.

kumabon commented 1 year ago

Same issue for me here. Same version of macOS / Safari / Strongbox.

One additional note for case 1, while I cannot select the suggested entries using mouse click or keyboard, I could use Touch ID to "click" after I mouseover an entry. My database remains unlocked the entire time.

Using Touch ID is not always convenient for me, as my MacBook Pro lid is often closed on my desktop.

Autofill / QuickType used to work previously. I am unable to pinpoint which recent update to macOS / Safari / Strongbox broke that feature

strongbox-mark commented 1 year ago

Hi, this appears to be an Apple bug, so please do raise this issue with Apple. We don’t control the QuickType UI and can only provide suggestions to it.

Kugelfang666 commented 1 year ago

ok, i see, thanks for the feedback, would it maybe make more sense if you as app developer would file a bug ? I assume that as an enduser the feedback might not get the necessary attention

kumabon commented 1 year ago

Perhaps it'd be useful to note that QuickType works fine with build-in password manager. i.e. mouse click and Enter keystroke can select an item. I haven't tried another password manager supporting QuickType to see if it is also a problem tho...

Are you able to replicate the problem?

strongbox-mark commented 1 year ago

We’re getting reports this is fixed in the latest Safari beta. We have raised this and other issues with Apple but unfortunately we’ve never received any kind of response when we raise these, even as developers. It just goes into a black hole. The more people complain the more likely it is they will look at the issue.

strongbox-mark commented 11 months ago

Closing out as we are not receiving any further complaints.

Kugelfang666 commented 11 months ago

Haven’t encountered this for quite some time, can be closed from my end

strongbox-mark commented 11 months ago

OK, fingers crossed Apple has fixed this in the meantime.

kumabon commented 11 months ago

Indeed the issue appears resolved for me as well.

macOS 13.5 Safari 16.6 Strongbox 1.58.17