Closed DaMandal0rian closed 4 weeks ago
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review [1-5] | 4, because the PR involves multiple changes across various configuration files and Terraform modules, which requires a detailed understanding of the infrastructure and the impact of these changes on the existing setup. |
๐งช Relevant tests | No |
โก Possible issues | Possible Bug: The removal of NS record creation in `aws_route53_record` and the addition of CAA records without ensuring DNS validation might cause issues with domain validation if not properly managed. |
Configuration Concern: Changing the default AWS region and hosted zone names across multiple environments without corresponding updates to dependent resources or documentation might lead to inconsistencies or deployment failures. | |
๐ Security concerns | No |
relevant file | eks/network/main.tf |
suggestion | Consider adding error handling or validation checks when modifying DNS settings, especially when disabling NS record creation. This can prevent potential issues with domain resolution and certificate validation. [important] |
relevant line | # Validate records for the new HostedZone (disable since ACM module will create the NS records) |
relevant file | eks/eks-blue/variables.tf |
suggestion | Ensure that the updated default values for AWS region and hosted zone are reflected in all dependent configurations and documentation to avoid deployment inconsistencies. [important] |
relevant line | default = "us-east-2" |
relevant file | eks/network/main.tf |
suggestion | When changing the domain name for the ACM module, ensure that all SANs (Subject Alternative Names) are correctly updated to prevent SSL/TLS certificate errors. [important] |
relevant line | domain_name = local.hosted_zone_name |
relevant file | eks/network/secrets.tf |
suggestion | Verify that the new secret names for SSH keys are updated across all scripts and CI/CD pipelines to prevent issues with access to private repositories. [important] |
relevant line | name = "github-eks-subspace-ssh-key" |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Best practice |
Add a validation check for the hosted zone name to ensure it meets DNS naming standards___ **Consider adding a validation check forlocal.hosted_zone_name to ensure it conforms to DNS naming conventions before using it in resource definitions. This can prevent runtime errors due to invalid domain names.** [eks/network/main.tf [51]](https://github.com/subspace/infra/pull/315/files#diff-9a53583c0fb470e0caf937b2459bf9506a6737031a32d9ae07e3d9c22ea615a6R51-R51) ```diff -name = local.hosted_zone_name +name = can(regex("^[a-zA-Z0-9-]{1,63}\\.[a-zA-Z0-9-.]{1,253}$", local.hosted_zone_name)) ? local.hosted_zone_name : "default.example.com" ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Adding a validation check for the hosted zone name is a best practice that can prevent runtime errors due to invalid domain names, which is crucial for maintaining the stability and reliability of the infrastructure. | 9 |
Make the ACM validation wait conditional based on the environment___ **It's recommended to handle thewait_for_validation flag dynamically based on the environment (e.g., true for production). Hardcoding it to false might skip necessary validation steps that can catch misconfigurations.** [eks/network/main.tf [82]](https://github.com/subspace/infra/pull/315/files#diff-9a53583c0fb470e0caf937b2459bf9506a6737031a32d9ae07e3d9c22ea615a6R82-R82) ```diff -wait_for_validation = false +wait_for_validation = var.environment == "production" ? true : false ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Dynamically handling the `wait_for_validation` flag based on the environment ensures that necessary validation steps are not skipped in production, enhancing the reliability and correctness of the deployment process. | 8 | |
Enhance tagging for ACM resources for improved management and tracking___ **Thetags for the ACM module only include the Name tag. It's a good practice to include more descriptive tags such as Environment , ManagedBy , etc., for better resource management and cost tracking.** [eks/network/main.tf [86]](https://github.com/subspace/infra/pull/315/files#diff-9a53583c0fb470e0caf937b2459bf9506a6737031a32d9ae07e3d9c22ea615a6R86-R86) ```diff tags = { - Name = "${local.hosted_zone_name}" + Name = "${local.hosted_zone_name}", + Environment = var.environment_name, + ManagedBy = "Terraform" } ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: Adding more descriptive tags such as `Environment` and `ManagedBy` improves resource management and cost tracking, which is beneficial for maintaining organized and well-documented infrastructure. | 6 | |
Maintainability |
Parameterize CAA records to increase flexibility and manageability___ **The hardcoded CAA records limit the issuance of certificates to "amazon.com". If other CAsare needed in the future, this might restrict operations. Consider parameterizing the CAA records or managing them through a different configuration layer.** [eks/network/main.tf [68]](https://github.com/subspace/infra/pull/315/files#diff-9a53583c0fb470e0caf937b2459bf9506a6737031a32d9ae07e3d9c22ea615a6R68-R68) ```diff -records = ["0 issue \"amazon.com\"", "0 issuewild \"amazon.com\""] +records = var.caa_records ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Parameterizing CAA records allows for greater flexibility and future-proofing, making it easier to adapt to changes in certificate authorities without modifying the code. | 7 |
PR Type
enhancement, configuration changes
Description
Changes walkthrough ๐
9 files
variables.tf
Update default values for AWS region, hosted zone, and GitHub SSH key
eks/eks-blue/variables.tf
us-east-2
eks.subspace.network
variables.tf
Update default AWS region
eks/eks-green/variables.tf - Changed default AWS region to `us-east-2`
secrets.tf
Update GitHub SSH key names in Secrets Manager
eks/network/secrets.tf - Updated GitHub SSH key names in Secrets Manager
variables.tf
Update default AWS region
eks/network/variables.tf - Changed default AWS region to `us-east-2`
main.tf
Update cluster endpoint to new AWS region
eks/user_data/main.tf - Updated cluster endpoint to `us-east-2`
variables.tf
Update default hosted zone and GitHub SSH key name
templates/terraform/aws/eks/eks_cluster/variables.tf
eks.subspace.network
terraform.tfvars
Add terraform.tfvars for EKS blue environment
eks/eks-blue/terraform.tfvars
GitHub SSH key
terraform.tfvars
Add terraform.tfvars for EKS green environment
eks/eks-green/terraform.tfvars
GitHub SSH key
terraform.tfvars
Add terraform.tfvars for network configuration
eks/network/terraform.tfvars - Added variables for AWS region, environment name, and hosted zone
2 files
main.tf
Simplify hosted zone and update ACM configuration
eks/network/main.tf
main.tf
Simplify EKS cluster domain and update Route53 zone data source
templates/terraform/aws/eks/eks_cluster/main.tf