Standard list of activity tags

[quozl]

Recent development as part of GSoC 2018 has added tags to many of the core Fructose activities, with several side-effects showing up during integration;

• the List View (F2 ctrl+2) shows the tags in a comma separated list under the activity name,

• the List View search feature finds activities with tags,

• the tags are not translated into the configured language,

• the tags are somewhat inconsistently applied.

tags is briefly defined in https://github.com/sugarlabs/sugar-toolkit-gtk3/blob/master/src/sugar3/bundle/__init__.py#L72

We need;

• [x] a standard list of tags,
• [ ] translations of the tags.

CC: @vipulgupta2048

Screenshot of List View after searching for "documen";

[vipulgupta2048]

a standard list of tags

Like @quozl mentioned and after going over a lot of activities for my project in GSoC 2018. The tags parameter was introduced to maintain uniformity in terms of the classification of activities. The list of tags below can be considered as standard if the community agrees on it.

Programming, Robotics, Internet, Science, Maths, Language, Geography, Documents, Music, Media, Art, Teacher, or System.

Apart from the tags listed above, I have also proposed the use of Tools which can be classified as activities that are essential and increases productivity. I might not have noticed Utilities not being the list of tags in https://github.com/sugarlabs/sugar-toolkit-gtk3/blob/master/src/sugar3/bundle/__init__.py#L72 . Leading to the tag being present in the write activity,

SO, if we could have a vote between Utilities or Tools, then we could add the same in #400

translations of the tags.

Google Translate seems like a good option. I have very little idea about the method for translations at Sugar Labs.

[quozl]

@vipulgupta2048, actually the tags metadata feature was already there, it's just that your project began to use it for aslo-v3 and so you began populating it. That's why it is starting to show up in List View.

Tools is as ambiguous as Activity. I don't think Tools has any meaning.

Utilities would more commonly mean programs that act on system or storage components; like the Journal, Frame, Neighbourhood View, or the hidden Log and Terminal activities.

That productivity is increased is a value judgement disconnected from child learning; the Maze game will increase productivity by improving visual perception; the Implode game will increase productivity by improving problem solving ability, etc.

@walterbender, is there a software classification system used in pedagogy?

[tony37]

I can see no benefit in cluttering the List view with these tags. The activity has been installed or it wouldn't be visible in the List View. The user's only options are to delete the activity or to make it visible in the Home view.

Sugar is deviating grossly from its guidelines. This change adds to the translation burden. The VIews were designed to be usable by icons not requiring words. Now young learners whose native language is not English will need to cope with more words which may be important to their use of Sugar but can be safely ignored. Teachers will need to be trained that these categories are not relevant to their students - who will inevitably raise thier hands to ask.

Tony

On Thursday, 09 August, 2018 07:09 AM, James Cameron wrote:

Recent development as part of GSoC 2018 has added /tags/ to many of the core Fructose activities, with several side-effects showing up during integration;

*

the List View (F2 ctrl+2) shows the tags in a comma separated list
under the activity name,

*

the List View search feature finds activities with tags,

*

the tags are not translated into the configured language,

*

the tags are somewhat inconsistently applied.

/tags/ is briefly defined in https://github.com/sugarlabs/sugar-toolkit-gtk3/blob/master/src/sugar3/bundle/__init__.py#L72

We need;

• a standard list of tags,
• translations of the tags.

CC: @vipulgupta2048 https://github.com/vipulgupta2048

Screenshot of List View after searching for "documen";

screenshot_ubb_2018-08-09_15 07 06 https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/2936481/43879203-222182d2-9be6-11e8-9ac4-d05aebe9e802.png

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/sugarlabs/sugar-toolkit-gtk3/issues/399, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAULkuNTo8XiqBdcoJe-mVCbyF8CDziJks5uO8QVgaJpZM4V1DXd.

[quozl]

The presentation of tags was added by Tomeu in 2009, so it not true to say this is a gross deviation. Also it only appears in List View, so hand raising will be a good learning opportunity.

Adding tags to activities as has just happened does however add a translation burden, and that's my biggest concern. If this can't be resolved, I'll pull them out. @leonardcj, as translations manager, what's your opinion?

@vipulgupta2048, translation is handled by a team who use https://translate.sugarlabs.org/ ... use of Google Translate is often unreliable, as there is insufficient context for the algorithm to pick a word from several.

[tony37]

I don't remember the details - but at that time the intent was to enable a search by tags (primarily the Journal). I don't believe this was in connection with a 'standard list' but more with tags supplied by the user in the language of their choice.

Tony

On Saturday, 11 August, 2018 09:12 AM, James Cameron wrote:

The presentation of tags was added by Tomeu in 2009 https://github.com/sugarlabs/sugar/commit/014a004eb2a708bd368f494e98a6c3705495cf76, so it not true to say this is a gross deviation. Also it only appears in List View, so hand raising will be a good learning opportunity.

Adding tags to activities as has just happened does however add a translation burden, and that's my biggest concern. If this can't be resolved, I'll pull them out. @leonardcj https://github.com/leonardcj, as translations manager, what's your opinion?

@vipulgupta2048 https://github.com/vipulgupta2048, translation is handled by a team who use https://translate.sugarlabs.org/ ... use of Google Translate is often unreliable, as there is insufficient context for the algorithm to pick a word from several.

— You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/sugarlabs/sugar-toolkit-gtk3/issues/399#issuecomment-412256906, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAULkpCFisrlp8k2Rs6Yr8izpsEIGJBEks5uPoP7gaJpZM4V1DXd.

[quozl]

No, the Journal metadata tags are entirely different. Here in this issue we are dealing with activity tags, which enhance the search of the activity List View.