superduper / BrightnessMenulet

BrightnessMenulet is an Mac OS X app that allows you to control display brightness via DDC/CI protocol
433 stars 91 forks source link

Makes my Macbook Pro Retina crash #3

Open mfoll opened 11 years ago

mfoll commented 11 years ago

When I launch the program, my Macbook Pro Retina immediately freezes and I can only force it to shut down. It happens with or without on external display plugged in. (OS X 10.8.4)

RSully commented 10 years ago

Same here. It looks like it doesn't actually crash, just the displays don't update.

jeske commented 10 years ago

same here... as soon as I launch it, my display locks up. The machine seems to still be runnning, because my music is still playing, but the mouse won't move and I can't do anything but hard-restart.

StyleT commented 9 years ago

+1 for me (OSX 10.9.5, Hackintosh)

kamenitxan commented 9 years ago

Same for me

tamsky commented 9 years ago

+1 (OSX 10.10.2, MBP11,3) I was hopeful, but same freeze of input devices. Display does not freeze as time/seconds still update in menubar.

darezik commented 9 years ago

Um, it works on DDC/CI, meant for external third party displays, not internal. Maybe it's getting confused between your laptops primary display and the external? 

_____________________________

From:Marc Tamsky

Subject:Re: [BrightnessMenulet] Makes my Macbook Pro Retina crash (#3)

To:superduper/BrightnessMenulet

+1 (OSX 10.10.2, MBP11,3) I was hopeful, but same freeze of input devices. Display does not freeze as time/seconds still update in menubar.

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub.

tamsky commented 9 years ago

Laptop primary display is closed and off. Should not be active. But, maybe?

sodabrew commented 9 years ago

Also hangs the display on my Mac mini 2012 running OS X Yosemite 10.10.2 with a Dell via mDP. In top the process is reported as stuck and dtruss -p reports this trace for minutes at a time:

Invalid connection: com.apple.coresymbolicationd
SYSCALL(args)        = return
tarasbilinsky commented 9 years ago

same here freezes the system, macbook with retina display and 2 monitors connected Dell and SAmsung

koenpunt commented 9 years ago

This has probably to do with the DisplayPort interface on those devices. The updated DDC implementation from https://github.com/kfix/ddcctl could resolve this issue. I got the project compiling, without the system freezing, but the brightness adjusting doesn't work either..

wise-rice commented 9 years ago

Hey Guys, This awesome tweak crashes my non -retina macbook as well IF i leave my Dell Monitor connected when I open the app. If the dell is first disconnected- then the app is started and then de Dell is connected everything works fine! But thats not very apple-like...

So who could tell me how to use kfix instead? I dont really understand much of the coding / compiling stuff you are talking about. But if I try to install kfix ddcctl using the "make install" command - i get an error message with 5 different problems in it ...

Any help,coding masters ??

simonsmith commented 9 years ago

Same issue here too:

screen shot 2015-09-08 at 09 13 10
mhuusko5 commented 9 years ago

Same issue, 13" 2015 MBP retina.

mafredri commented 9 years ago

Crashes my Macbook Pro as well (Late 2013, Retina). I have a pair of Dell U2715H displays and I believe the crashes are related to reading the current values from the monitor. I have managed to use kfix/ddcctl to set the display contrast, however, if I use this version to read the values (e.g. increase brightness with +5) I get an instant OS freeze.

manfromanotherland commented 8 years ago

Crashes on mine too.

MacBook Pro (Mid 2012) with El Capitan. I have a Dell U2713HM connected via DisplayPort.

sodabrew commented 8 years ago

Here's an awesome fork that does work on OS X 10.10 and 10.11: https://github.com/Kalvin126/BrightnessMenulet

manfromanotherland commented 8 years ago

@sodabrew That did the job. Thank you so much!