superkhau / lice

An open source license generator and license viewer.
MIT License
55 stars 7 forks source link

add transcopyright license #7

Closed ghost closed 1 year ago

ghost commented 1 year ago

Hi.

I added the transcopyright license - this license is a "deliberative license". transcopyright is used for the xanadu project by Ted Nelson (one of the creators of hypertext, hypermedia etc). The deliberative license model is different from the restrictive model (AGPL, GPLv2, GPLv3 etc) or the permissive model (MIT, BSD etc). In the deliberative license model it is something between copyright and copyleft, something similar to what I believe is CC (Creative Commons).

For example, if the work is licensed under transcopyright and some part modified or not is MIT, this could include both proprietary and non-proprietary things. If the work is licensed under transcopyright and and some part modified or not is GPLv3, the mixed licenses include the parts that make up the GPLv3 and contrary licenses such as MIT or proprietary as well.

These two cases occur, because the transcopyright license understands that the code is composed of isolated or separate parts (from what I initially understood). So, you only license what can or should be licensed. It's a way of having a copyright in a copyleft way. I think it would be something between a "non-copyright" or "non-copyleft" - it's like a "copy-left-right-center" - this license allows mixing software, whether they have this license or another more permissive one or not (provided that part is also licensed or assigned under transcopyright).

Some may interpret this as copyright. But it's not from what I've read and understood, since the concept behind transcopyright is different from copyright. Also, most open projects include duplicate license models (you include part open source and part closed source - for example, open core business model. Or when you want to keep something open with funding from some company or own technology)

This license does not restrict copyright or copy-left use, meaning it is accessible to anyone. This license, in my view, is interesting to be added, despite being controversial to add it.

what is deliberative license or "copy-left-right-center" license or "copy-left-center"? The idea of a deliberative or "copy-left-right-center" license is generally the copy center - while granting certain permissions to the people who own those copies, as long as those copies are licensed under the same license. But this can only be done if people who also have their own permissions on the one hand. Which is interesting in my view, as it seems something like a balance between licenses like BSD, MIT, Unlicensed, PublicDomain, GPL.

scenario

update

why are you adding this license? or why are you contributing to our repository?

ralyodio commented 1 year ago

LGTM

ghost commented 1 year ago

Hi ralyodio.

LGTM

thanks for comment here.

superkhau commented 1 year ago

Thanks @ghost, even though we don't know who you are + @ralyodio for reviewing as usual. 💪🏻