Shorter NSStringWithFormat

[iluuu1994]

As you all know, [NSString stringWithFormat:@"...", ...] is a lot of syntax for something so common. This is why ObjectiveSugar implemented the NSStringWithFormat function. It is indeed shorter, but well... not a lot.

How about a format: method on NSString? [@"..." format:...] would be much more appealing in my opinion.

I will implement this method and update the tests and doc if anyone finds this useful.

[zenangst]

+1, love it.

[3lvis]

:+1:

[supermarin]

How about -withFormat?

That'd give it a perfect hint, altho the choice is on you. Love the idea.

[iluuu1994]

@supermarin Agreed.

Great! I'll create a pull-request soon.

[neilco]

I think it should be formatWithArgs since it would work in this way [formatString formatWithArgs:arg1, arg2, ...]

If you wanted to shorten it, I'd be OK with withArgs although it loses some clarity.

[supermarin]

Hm, that makes sense; altho it could get verbose-y again. Here're the examples written down

[@"Hello %@" format:@"world"];
[@"Hello %@" withFormat:@"world"];
[@"Hello %@" withArgs:@"world"];
[@"Hello %@" formatWithArgs:@"world"];

[NSString stringWithFormat:@"Hello %@", @"world"];
NSStringWithFormat(@"Hello", @"world");

@iluuu1994 it's also worth pointing out that the main goal of NSStringWithFormat wasn't shortening, it was more avoiding bracketception and improving readability.

[neilco]

Agreed. See this comparison:

[@"Hello %@" formatWithArgs:@"world"];
NSStringWithFormat(@"Hello %@", @"world");

I think the latter is much clearer to read.

[iluuu1994]

@neilco Good point.

I like withArgs:, although formatWithArgs: would be clearer. It's your repo, so I guess you guys decide.

[iluuu1994]

@supermarin

that the main goal of NSStringWithFormat wasn't shortening, it was more avoiding bracketception

Well if that's the case my idea isn't worth a lot. Let me see if I find a more elegant solution. Until then, I'll close the issue.

[supermarin]

fair enough, thanks @iluuu1994!