search

surge-synthesizer / surge

Synthesizer plug-in (previously released as Vember Audio Surge)
https://surge-synthesizer.github.io/
GNU General Public License v3.0
3.08k stars 394 forks source link

Over zooming of ui VST3 #7396

Open hfiguiere opened 9 months ago

hfiguiere commented 9 months ago

Bug Description: Surge over zoom the UI in Ardour 8.

Surge XT Version 1.2.3 or 1.3.0

Reproduction Steps: Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. Start Ardour
  2. In Ardour preference set a font size to 125%. (it's still too small on my 4K screen)
  3. Create track in Ardour to use Surge XT VST3
  4. Open the UI. It's too big.

Expected Behavior: The UI is properly sized.

Screenshots: Screenshot from 2023-12-13 16-16-58

Computer Information (please complete the following!):

Additional Information: Source: https://github.com/flathub/org.surge_synth_team.surge-xt/pull/15#issuecomment-1854755320

tl;dr Ardour give the UI scale to the plugin. And the plugins seenm to do it twice. I can't even change the ui zoom in Surge. Also 150%, I get the black window.

https://github.com/flathub/org.surge_synth_team.surge-xt/pull/15#issuecomment-1854774369

hfiguiere commented 9 months ago

Just to clarify, the above screenshot is NOT edited. The crop was taken as is.

mkruselj commented 9 months ago

I think this is an issue on Ardour end, as I don't think we see the same behavior in any other VST3 host.

(By the way, you can right-click in the background of the GUI to get the main menu of Surge, which also has the zoom options.)

baconpaul commented 9 months ago

i'll find some time to download ardour 8 and try hopefully before christmas

sounds to me like it is sending me the vst3 setting for screen pixel scaling as its internal scale.

miranda commented 6 months ago

I just installed Surge XT 1.3 on Arch Linux (via pacman), using it with Ardour 8... discovered the same thing. It's so huge it won't fit on my screen. But I also noticed none of the zoom or shrink settings do anything at all, even trying to enlarge it. I also noticed that it has the option "Set Current Zoom Level (250%) as Default" and "Set Default Zoom Level to..." brings up 250 to start with, and setting it to a different number won't change it. So it's obviously stuck at 250% zoom.

Another thing that it's doing is when I bring up the menu and move the mouse between selections, the Surge UI completely disappears and only the menu is visible. Not sure if that is related.

mkruselj commented 6 months ago

I really really think this is a bug in Ardour...

erikjms commented 4 months ago

Might this bug be related?

Ardour: VST3 Plug-In GUIs cannot be resized smaller than the size at the most recent project save

It's the most recent bug I can find that looks at all relevant on Ardour's bug tracker. It's been open since 2021. I have not tried the workarounds suggested but will.

In the meantime, setting Ardour GUI scale back to 100% and restarting makes Surge's GUI zoomable again. Tweaking presets in tiny Ardour and then using them in readable Ardour is somewhat cumbersome, but since they both do exactly what I want otherwise, that is what I have been doing.

I'd be grateful if you all could talk to the Ardour devs about this when you have a chance. I do not have the resources to argue-- or, um, discuss this with them. Making noise/music is much more life-affirming. :)

mkruselj commented 4 months ago

I suppose this means we could probably close this issue if it's confirmed on Ardour's end (which was my suspicion from the get go).

mkruselj commented 4 months ago

@baconpaul Thoughts on the above?

baconpaul commented 4 months ago

I was going to test it next time i was in linux. Lets leave it be open for now on the odd chance that up upgrade to juce 7.0.12 for #7640 also helps