Closed edgy-sphere closed 1 month ago
i'm seeing the same issue that everything in $page is "lagging behind", i.e. on page initialisation it still contains the data from the last route. However when accessed within onMount
the data is correct. This is when using Svelte 5. With Svelte 4 $page
has the correct data even outside onMount
. Is this intended behaviour with Svelte 5? This would be unfortunate since it makes the code more complex. I assume $page.route.id
and $page.params
should be known even outside of onMount
.
After upgrading to SvelteKit2 I'm seeing this behavior on a Svelte4-only project. I will try to find the time to provide a reproduction.
Edit: after further testing it looks like $page is not really "lagging behind" but rather two versions of $page (the old and the new) can exist at the same time (can switch from one to the other by navigating), I don't know if this is conceptually the same thing or not.
Edit: after further testing it looks like $page is not really "lagging behind" but rather two versions of $page (the old and the new) can exist at the same time (can switch from one to the other by navigating)
I can confirm that I think I'm seeing this behaviour (with svelte 4) as well — when I invalidate my load
function that puts data into page
, it updates as expected. When navigating to a new route it seems to revert back to the previous value of page
, but if I get the data in the route it's correct
I've tested this with Svelte 5 and it fixes the issue. I'm not sure if this is something we can fix in Kit itself (without notifying the page store twice). I'll close this issue but would like to know what others think. cc: @benmccann @dummdidumm
Describe the bug
Background
I would like to have easy-to-use search filters for an item collection. To allow for bookmarking and opening in a new tab, a suggested filter should just be a link with the corresponding filter added to the URL search params.
Issue
This involves reading the current search params and per suggested filter creating a link, adding a search param to it. Using the page store directly in a component's script does not work properly, but appears to "lag behind" one page, presumably due to the page store being updated only after the component update/render. This only applies for links to the same path—see at path
/fixed
the linkTEST HOME "year=2019"
, which works as intended; presumably because no components are reused.Reproduction
Repo link: https://github.com/edgy-sphere/sveltekit-page-store-updates-after-component
git clone https://github.com/edgy-sphere/sveltekit-page-store-updates-after-component.git
npm i
npm run dev
localhost:5173
in a contemporary browser.Case A
(on path
/
) click e.g. on Parasite's year2019
, then the director links for both Parasite and 1917 only include the respective director instead of also includingyear=2019
in their search params. Clicking theTest Director
button logs the correct link to everyone's favourite, the developer console.Case B
Following Case A (not using the same URL, e.g.
/?year=2019
, instead you must navigate there from home/
), click onHOME
, then the links of the first two movies erroneously includeyear=2019
as well—not the next four, I guess because the corresponding components of these are created, while the components of the first two are reused.Logs
No response
System Info
Severity
annoyance
Additional Information
Similar issues
Workaround
When providing the page store as an argument to
hrefFilter(...)
(atmovie.svelte
) and not using it directly, all works as expected—see at path/fixed
.Solution
Updating the page store before the component seems (to me) more reasonable, as components may rely on the page store while not vice versa.
While a simple workaround exists, it may not be immediately obvious to everyone. In any case, this issue hopefully will provide some help.
Please apologise that I am not providing any practical help toward fixing this, as I am not sure whether this actually works as intended, could not quite understand how components are reused, and since my mediocre coding skills compared to my Git proficiency appear like I am expert-master of the universe.