search

svrooij / sonos2mqtt

:speaker: Sonos mqtt controller. Control your speakers from your mqtt server. mqtt-smarthome insprired.
https://sonos2mqtt.svrooij.io/
MIT License
76 stars 18 forks source link

Grouped speakers get the status "playing"? #62

Closed matthias-burgfried closed 4 years ago

matthias-burgfried commented 4 years ago

Hello, I have observed a behavior that I do not understand. When I group a player (player 1) with a second player (player 2), the status of player 1 is "playing", although both players are not playing anything (they are stopped or paused). Is this behavior intended?

svrooij commented 4 years ago

If your group a player with another, there is one “coordinator” that controls the playback, and the queue. The other player (the one listening to the coordinator) is actually playing the empty stream from the coordinator.

I’m not sure on how to solve this, maybe group playback status is a nice feature, what’s your opinion about that?

matthias-burgfried commented 4 years ago

It would be fine, but I'm not sure if this is the most suitable solution. I installed node-sonos-http-api (https://github.com/jishi/node-sonos-http-api), where the grouped speaker shows the status of the coordinator. What do you think of this solution?

svrooij commented 4 years ago

Why not just "disable" the player in the ui if it's grouped? You can see the group events. In the official sonos app you can also not interact with the "child" players. You first have to ungroup them. What is the use case you're trying to solve?

Maybe an extra group-playback could be a thing. But I think it's a bad idea to something different then the current playback status retrieved from the speaker.

matthias-burgfried commented 4 years ago

Sorry for my late answer. I have a somewhat complicated setting. In the living room I have a PLAY:5 and a One. Unfortunately, you can't assign these two speakers to one room, so I usually (not always) grouped them. If a radio station is played in the kitchen and the two loudspeakers in the living room should be added by a button (via node-red), then this doesn't work so easily/it often fails because I don't know if the two loudspeakers are already grouped or not.

svrooij commented 4 years ago

Closing this stale issue, if someone wants to fix this, please re-open and create a PR.