search

swiss-art-research-net / reference-data-models

Reference Data Models discussions and integrations
8 stars 1 forks source link

Misalignment Graph-Table: Person>Educational Training #4

Open ncarboni opened 4 years ago

ncarboni commented 4 years ago

Spotted by @VladimirAlexiev on twitter:

Education is described but not illustrated? Is the educational institution captured?

To fix

ncarboni commented 4 years ago

educational training is now in the graph. The way I see it, is that we can link the activity to a place and then link a legal body to the place. However, there would not be a direct link between the pursuit and a specific organisation. @Habennin any thoughts?

Habennin commented 4 years ago

The SARI models were crafted taking into account existing data standards around certain types of entities and trying to abstract commonly documented properties relative to those entities.

Under this rubric the 'educational training' descriptor was abstracted and a semantic mapping created for it relative to the semantic content of the 'subject of study'. But is has been robustly mapped, using the 'Pursuit' class of FRBRoo, so in principle this pursuit event could be enriched with more data.

Off the top of my head, if we were to expand this node based on a particular need to track educational history, I might put the educational insinuation (E74) as one of the actors carrying out (p14) the activity, probably using p14.1 to indicate that it was the educational institution. I would offer that as an alternative to your suggestion @ncarboni just because it seems like indicating the place might be for the larger geographic area.

George studied philosophy in Athens at the National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

I could also have studied at a distance from Thessaloniki, but I still would have studied at NKUA. It seems that the NKUA is just a co-participant in the action, to me.

ncarboni commented 4 years ago

Agree. To add it on the fields. Would you do it @Habennin ?