search

sybrew / the-seo-framework

The SEO Framework WordPress plugin.
https://theseoframework.com/
GNU General Public License v3.0
417 stars 47 forks source link

Content Quality Reviews #108

Open sybrew opened 7 years ago

sybrew commented 7 years ago

I think it's finally time!

Prior discussions: A (focus keyword) B (general)

ETA 2018

Let's discuss content quality reviews!

Keep in mind: This is the initial draft!

This will ultimately be put into two different categories:

  1. Free Extension (internal review)
  2. Premium Extension (internal + external review)

They can actually be combined in one Free extension, that determines the subscription status to determine the use of external services (SaaS).

Internal review:

It includes checking for the post type, for example a "Post". Then it will then determine these factors, i.e. a checklist:

  1. Is your title set and will it fit in Google (pixel guidelines)?
  2. Will your description fit in Google (pixel guidelines)?
  3. Is it a post, and is a featured image set?
  4. Is there a social image found?
  5. etc.

External review:

It will have to fetch SEO and content data set from the post. From there, it will then determine these factors too:

  1. Does the metadata match with the input data?
  2. How's the code quality?
  3. How's the page performance regarding to load time?
  4. Is there an AMP version?
  5. Is it indexed in Google, Bing, etc. yet?
  6. Is it found in the sitemap?
  7. Is there a sharing button?
  8. Has the post been shared on Facebook or Twitter?
  9. etc.

Most of these can be checked manually, but an automated version is nice too. Note that not all factors are sufficient for each site, some are even counterproductive. Therefore, a predetermined set based on the "type of website" has to be initiated.

Let me know what you are looking for!

My plan is to include a tab, for now. The tab is passive, and will only test data on request (AJAX) with a change listener. This is to reduce CPU usage; and so, you'll enjoy a longer battery life and smoother browsing experience.

A few examples:

What do you want to be reviewed?

  1. I'd like the Flesch–Kincaid score to be reviewed.
  2. I'd like this to be reviewed.

What do you expect?

  1. It has to check for content, descriptions and titles.
  2. It has to check for such and so.
sybrew commented 6 years ago

This extension will be brought with the subject analysis extension: #128.

RicaNeaga commented 6 years ago

Hello! Please see a review for your plugin (wrote today in english by a well-known SEO expert from my country) - https://olivian.ro/seo-framework-plugin/

The last point is related to this ticket / future feature of your plugin. Hope it helps :)

sybrew commented 3 years ago

From marcowhich's comments, regarding "Adding Cornerstone content":

[W]hen you set a page as "Cornerstone", [it] then suggests internal linking from other related pages. [...] This matters when you have a large inventory of posts and pages. [...]

I’m guessing to add this feature, the plugin needs to have some [sort] of content quality assessment ability. This might be a good thing. But at the same time, it’s a double-edged sword and might make the code more sluggish.

Related: https://github.com/sybrew/the-seo-framework/issues/124