search

sylveon / discord-ban-appeals

Sample ban appeals page with OAuth2 integration
https://discord-ban-appeal-preview.netlify.app/
MIT License
137 stars 45 forks source link

Collect user's email #19

Open NoodlesDev987 opened 3 years ago

NoodlesDev987 commented 3 years ago

Add option to collect also user's email from Discord oauth. Then staff will be able to reply to the appeal to user's email. Replying to email is better for staff than sending friend requests and waiting for approval ...

jcsumlin commented 3 years ago

I feel like this is maybe unnecessary since the user's name/discriminator is/can be collected. If an admin needed to reach out it would probably be best to do so within the discord ecosystem rather than exposing a user's or admin's personal information.

sylveon commented 3 years ago

Yes, one of the selling points of Discord over other services is email and IP privacy.

This site already blurs the line on the latter because nothing stops the server owner from, for example, logging IPs. I think this would work better with #18, so one can add a question asking for email, and any good faith appeal could put in an email. Another reason for not collecting the email from OAuth is that the user might not want to use their main Discord account email, because it could be on an inbox they don't check regularly for example.

Of course, the peak would be for this system to automatically send emails on approved appeals and never directly expose them to the owner/mods, but it would quickly kill the easy to setup and free to host aspect of this project (would need a database, a service to send emails, etc.)

jcsumlin commented 3 years ago

@sylveon Ill have to double-check since it's been a while since I've worked on it, but the ReactJS take on your app that I've published (jcsumlin/discord-ban-appeal) DM's the banned user (or tries to) once the ban appeal has been approved.

sylveon commented 3 years ago

Didn't think of that, genius!

NoodlesDev987 commented 3 years ago

Ok