search

symbuzzer / systemless-hosts-KernelSU-module

Required module to use applications such as AdAway on KernelSU and APatch
GNU General Public License v3.0
346 stars 10 forks source link

Banking apps not working with this module installed #4

Closed ashoktvm closed 9 months ago

ashoktvm commented 1 year ago

As you already know some banking apps still not working with module installed. Hope you are still working on this

symbuzzer commented 1 year ago

As you already know some banking apps still not working with module installed. Hope you are still working on this

At this stage, it does not seem possible to understand how these practitioners realize this. They're probably noticing that DNS requests are filtering through the hosts file, and that's how they detect it. But I'm not sure.

hsantanna commented 1 year ago

From tests, the apps detect the module itself, not the hosts filtering.

I disable AdAway and reboot, but the apps still detect the module.

So I remove the module from KernelSU and reboot, and that way the apps won't detect anything wrong and starts to work.

symbuzzer commented 1 year ago

Can you uninstall this and try my Turkish Ad Hosts from my Github please?

ashoktvm commented 1 year ago

Can you uninstall this and try my Turkish Ad Hosts from my Github please?

Adaway doesn't work with Turkish host installed

symbuzzer commented 1 year ago

No. Only check banking app please

ashoktvm commented 1 year ago

No. Only check banking app please

It didnt created issue for Banking app. But the goal here is to work both adaway and Banking app right?

symbuzzer commented 1 year ago

No. Only check banking app please

It didnt created issue for Banking app. But the goal here is to work both adaway and Banking app right?

If you could confirm that the bank application works fine with TAH, will try to port its technic to this module. But I see that you find it more appropriate to question rather than help.

I took note of your feedback. But at this stage, I can't help because there is no banking application that I can test for Turkey...

ashoktvm commented 1 year ago

No. Only check banking app please

It didnt created issue for Banking app. But the goal here is to work both adaway and Banking app right? If you could confirm that the bank application works fine with TAH, will try to port its technic to this module. But I see that you find it more appropriate to question rather than help.

I took note of your feedback. But at this stage, I can't help because there is no banking application that I can test for Turkey...

I was not questioning. But u were not clear to test it with a banking app or Adaway. Sorry if it felt like being rude

symbuzzer commented 1 year ago

@ashoktvm @hsantanna Can you try my other module, adaway-kernelsu-helper and give feedback please?

One user, who I'm not sure what to do, reported that his device was bootlooped. However, I did not encounter such a problem in my own tests. If you do not know how to recover the device, do not try.

ashoktvm commented 1 year ago

@ashoktvm @hsantanna Can you try my other module, adaway-kernelsu-helper and give feedback please?

One user, who I'm not sure what to do, reported that his device was bootlooped. However, I did not encounter such a problem in my own tests. If you do not know how to recover the device, do not try.

I was the one who tested it. Will try later. Cant afford to lose phone to bootloop now

ashoktvm commented 1 year ago

@ashoktvm @hsantanna Can you try my other module, adaway-kernelsu-helper and give feedback please?

One user, who I'm not sure what to do, reported that his device was bootlooped. However, I did not encounter such a problem in my own tests. If you do not know how to recover the device, do not try.

Hi. I have tested the module. There was no reboot issue in my Redmi Note 11. But adaway was not able to install hosts file

Lu5ck commented 12 months ago

I second this, installing this expose rooting, making it detectable by banks / government apps etc.

symbuzzer commented 12 months ago

I second this, installing this expose rooting, making it detectable by banks / government apps etc.

We already know this issue. But no solution for now. It is a cat-mouse game...

Lu5ck commented 11 months ago

I second this, installing this expose rooting, making it detectable by banks / government apps etc.

We already know this issue. But no solution for now. It is a cat-mouse game...

It seems like @HuskyDG already fixed this issue with https://github.com/HuskyDG/ksu_unmount_injector

Just found out as I saw this posted in KSU telegram group. So old kernels like 4.14, 4.19, 5.4, basically anything below 5.10 need to use this module. It is a must have module.

adi90x commented 11 months ago

Just try both adaway helper , and still detected by Microsoft Intune

adi90x commented 11 months ago

Hello,

This module @gloeyisk/systemless-hosts is able to modify host without being detected by Intune app. I guess detection is due to the overlay right ?

EDIT: Using @HuskyDG/ksu_unmount_injector adaway and Microsoft Intune works without any issue !

Regards,

symbuzzer commented 11 months ago

Hello,

This module @gloeyisk/systemless-hosts is able to modify host without being detected by Intune app. I guess detection is due to the overlay right ?

EDIT: Using @HuskyDG/ksu_unmount_injector adaway and Microsoft Intune works without any issue !

Regards,

Yes, even my [Turkish Ad Hosts] module does not cause any problems.

symbuzzer commented 9 months ago

Please read latest README.md