sympa-community / sympa

Sympa, Mailing List Management Software
https://www.sympa.community/sympa
GNU General Public License v2.0
241 stars 95 forks source link

DMARC rewrites switched #1678

Closed tmclaren closed 1 year ago

tmclaren commented 1 year ago

DKIM/DMARC/ARC - DMARC Protection (dmarc_protection) - New From name format(phrase)

These two rewrite options are switched:

Option 5 “List” (on behalf of e-mail) (list_for_email)
Generates: From: "mail-headers Mailing List" (on behalf of \"McLaren, Terry\") mail-headers@lists.illinois.edu

Optoin 6 “List” (on behalf of Name) (list_for_name) Generates: From: "mail-headers Mailing List" (on behalf of tmclaren@illinois.edu) mail-headers@lists.illinois.edu

Looks like a simple type-o fix for the pull down label.

Version

6.2.70

Installation method

rpm

Expected behavior

“List” (on behalf of e-mail) (list_for_email) should generate the email “List” (on behalf of Name) (list_for_name) shoudl generate a name

Update the pull down menu names to reflect the correct 'from' rewrite.

Actual behavior

“List” (on behalf of e-mail) (list_for_email) generates a name label. “List” (on behalf of Name) (list_for_name) generates an email label.

Steps to reproduce

Set the appropriate DMARC setting Send test message Review message header

Additional information

I'm in the process of characterizing email client behavior for displaying the 'from' field. Office 2019 vs. O365 vs. Gmail vs. Yahoo. The MS email clients seem ignore the 'from' header and derive it from other header tags, e.g. sender, X-Original-From.

ikedas commented 1 year ago

Duplicate of #1498 .