search

synfinatic / teensy-dsc

Teensy code & PCB design for digital setting circles
http://synfin.net/teensydsc
GNU General Public License v3.0
12 stars 5 forks source link

Switch WiFi solution? #22

Open synfinatic opened 10 years ago

synfinatic commented 10 years ago

So one problem with the Xbee/WiFly board I'm using is that it only supports a single TCP port. I suspect this makes it pretty much useless for things like serial to TCP adapter mode because you can't multiplex multiple tasks (like DSC) on the same TCP port.

Looks like the WizFi210/220 supports up to 16 ports (clients) and AP mode as well.

http://media.digikey.com/pdf/Data%20Sheets/WIZnet%20PDFs/WizFi210,220_UM_v1.12.pdf

The problem here of course is that it's not available in the XBee format and so would not be compatible with v0.5 boards, but of course the software would be so completely different it really doesn't matter anyways. Also, unlike the WiFly XBee module, they're sold either as Arduino shields, etc or individual chips. There doesn't seem to be any good/inexpensive break out boards so I'd have to design the board around this chip to do any development. (Or create my own xbee format breakout PCB)

The good news is that the boards are ~$32 via Digikey and appear reasonably easy to solder and will end up taking far less PCB space then the WiFly XBee shield.

Some useful Eagle .sch/.brd are available here:

UPDATE: Probably not a good pick. Looks like it only supports a single TCP server socket.

synfinatic commented 10 years ago

Another good option is the Bluegiga WF121. $30 via DigiKey. Has 4 UARTs and supports streaming them directly to TCP. There is also a nice breakout board & lots of good info about the WF121 here: http://www.inmojo.com/store/jeff-rowberg/item/wf121-wifi-breakout-board/

Resources:

Other:

synfinatic commented 9 years ago

Recently announced is the MediaTek 7681 which seems similar to the Bluegiga, but only $9: http://www.seeedstudio.com/depot/LinkIt-Connect7681-Module-Scale-for-Wifi-solution-p-2264.html

Dev kit is $20: http://www.seeedstudio.com/depot/LinkIt-Connect7681-Wifi-HDK-for-IoT-p-2262.html

https://labs.mediatek.com/site/global/developer_tools/mediatek_7681/whatis_7681/index.gsp

Looks like it supports up to 4 tcp server sockets & 4 connections. Only has a single UART so would have to multiplex it (use the 5 GPIO's for signaling?). Has a Windows & Linux SDK. 3.3V and low power requirements from the looks of it (no more then 250mA) and has onboard ceramic antenna!

synfinatic commented 9 years ago

ESP8266. http://www.esp8266.com/

By far the cheapest solution (< $5/ea). Supports softAP mode as well as AP client. Only a single UART as is common but has some GPIO which may be used for signaling. Uncertain if it can support > 1 TCP server socket. Sounds like the code is a bit unstable, but improving.

If I don't need multiple serial ports, this is probably the best option just because it's so small & cheap

https://github.com/beckdac/ESP8266-transparent-bridge may be useful

Available ESP8266 packaged as an XBee board is $6 + $6shipping:
http://www.dfrobot.com/wiki/index.php?title=SKU:TEL0092_WiFi_Bee-ESP8266_Wirelss_module http://www.dfrobot.com/index.php?route=product/product&product_id=1279&search=TEL0092&description=true

synfinatic commented 9 years ago

Another low cost WiFi solution. Not sure of it's featureset yet though: http://www.seeedstudio.com/depot/EMW3165-CortexM4-based-WiFi-SoC-Module-p-2488.html

There is also a dev board for it as well: http://www.seeedstudio.com/depot/EMWE-3165-A-Development-Board-p-2489.html

synfinatic commented 8 years ago

ESP8266 is definitely the low cost winner. At least for the current feature set, there's no need for anything more expensive!