Open catch-21 opened 4 months ago
Proposal: Once user taps on the toggle in the above scenario, automatically switch the toggle back to the off-state, and show a toast message: Heading: 'Transfer in Progress' Paragraph: 'Please wait for the transfer from your spending balance to your savings to be completed.'
Can't reproduce this, doesn't seem to me like the channel close transaction needs to be confirmed before ordering a new channel.
https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/5890c550-4d4a-4e8a-ac6e-8f969d68a648
Same with a force closed channel:
https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/891c41f2-3ef5-4b38-8756-20aa7bd91360
@pwltr Pretty sure this can be reproduced on mainnet. Check the link in description for deets.
@pwltr I can reproduce on staging.
From the receiver's perspective, the existing channel is receiving capacity is 1_583_020 (€888.78), close the channel and before confirmation produce a CJIT invoice:
https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/ee86afa7-a3a2-4554-b716-7b76b9218817
The sender cannot pay the CJIT invoice:
I would to opt to rely on Blocktank to return errors when making the channel order instead of keeping track of channel closing transactions. From Bitkit side the funds are immediately usable (for normal coop closes) so this would need additional logic to track confirmations of closed channels. Also this can depend on the channel size of the new channel so we shouldn't outright block transfers.
Since this is more of an edge case I think it should be handled like this:
We can improve the error msg but let's do it later if we hve more issues.
Blocktank prevents additional LN channel opening that would cause the Bitkit ldk node to exceed the maximum capacity. There is a scenario where, from the Bitkit user's perspective:
It would be good to either: a) prevent establishing a CJIT whilst it is known that Blocktank will prevent this. b) present a useful error to the receiving wallet when the connection is rejected (like "please wait for previous channel close tx to confirm")
See thread: https://synonymworkspace.slack.com/archives/C0726U60V6Y/p1716987787415509