dmaker.fan.p33 can only be set to 25, 50, 75 and 100%

[broekhuijsen]

I have both a dmaker.fan.p33 and a dmaker.fan.p18.

The dmaker.fan.p18 I can set from 1 to 100 %

The dmaker.fan.p33 can only be set to 25, 50, 75 and 100%

I have used the model: dmaker.fan.p18 option in the configuration to force it to think it is a dmaker.fan.p18 (the only difference should be the battery). But that does not seem to work either.

[syssi]

It looks like the implementation of the dmaker.fan.p33 is incomplete here:

    """
    TODO:
    - fan.turn_on works, but doesn't go to the declared percentage. This is
      not an issue when using set_percentage()
    - setting child lock works, but HA always reads the value as null
    """

https://github.com/syssi/xiaomi_fan/blob/develop/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py#L1877-L1882

You could use the set_percentage service as workaround but I guess you want to control the fan using the UI (lovelace) and the control element of the fan speed doesn't work?

[broekhuijsen]

Hi there, thanks for your response. Yes that is exactly the case. I want to use the slider in love lace. I don't know if it would be possible to create a number input and link that to a script that uses the set_percentage() to mimic this behaviour. But if the implementation is going to be finished in the near future I might as well just have some patience :D It is good to know that at least the problem as already known :D

[syssi]

Do you know how to put a custom_component into the custom_components folder to poke around a bit? :-)

[broekhuijsen]

Barely. I mean I can create a folder and copy files to that folder. But I have little knowledge about how to change code. If, it is usually google - copy - paste, rinse and repeat until I either accidentally do it correct (10%) or give up and feel frustrated (90%) :D

[syssi]

Do you use HACS to install custom components? I'm looking for a simple solution to provide a test version of this integration which fixes the issue.

[broekhuijsen]

I do use HACS yes. You want me to test anything? I have installed custom components before.

[syssi]

Yes. I've an idea what's going on here and will provide a fixed version later the day for testing.

[broekhuijsen]

Ok I'm happy to test it for you

Sent from Outlook for Androidhttps://aka.ms/AAb9ysg

---

From: Sebastian Muszynski @.> Sent: Saturday, August 31, 2024 11:11:14 AM To: syssi/xiaomi_fan @.> Cc: broekhuijsen @.>; Author @.> Subject: Re: [syssi/xiaomi_fan] dmaker.fan.p33 can only be set to 25, 50, 75 and 100% (Issue #276)

Yes. I've an idea what's going on here and will provide a fixed version later the day for testing.

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/syssi/xiaomi_fan/issues/276#issuecomment-2322851126, or unsubscribehttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AP7ITSTIEJSH42NGTQJLGK3ZUGJEFAVCNFSM6AAAAABNNBNBGSVHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43OSLTON2WKQ3PNVWWK3TUHMZDGMRSHA2TCMJSGY. You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID: @.***>

[syssi]

I've pushed a feature branch containing some fixes. Please use HACS to install the version of the feature branch:

1. Go to http:///developer-tools/action
2. Select "Chosse entity" and select the "Xiaomi Mi Smart Pedestal Fan Integration update" entity
3. Tick the version checkbox and set fix-p33-speed
4. Perform action
5. Restart Home Assistant

[broekhuijsen]

Ok, I followed your instructions but I get an error Failed to perform the action fan/set_percentage. 'speed

After that I deinstalled everything through HACS, reinstalled it, followed your instructions again, but still the same error.

I don't know if the log is of any use.

(I removed the log because it was showing a lot, but nothing more about the fan than what I posted below)

[broekhuijsen]

2024-08-31 15:04:07.844 WARNING (SyncWorker_0) [homeassistant.loader] We found a custom integration xiaomi_miio_fan which has not been tested by Home Assistant. This component might cause stability problems, be sure to disable it if you experience issues with Home Assistant File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 1034, in async_set_percentage File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 619, in _try_command File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 2090, in set_speed File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 1034, in async_set_percentage File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 619, in _try_command File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 2090, in set_speed File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 1034, in async_set_percentage File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 619, in _try_command File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 2090, in set_speed File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 1034, in async_set_percentage File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 619, in _try_command File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 2090, in set_speed File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 1034, in async_set_percentage File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 619, in _try_command File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 2090, in set_speed File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 1034, in async_set_percentage File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 619, in _try_command File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 2090, in set_speed File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 1034, in async_set_percentage File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 619, in _try_command File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 2090, in set_speed File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 1034, in async_set_percentage File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 619, in _try_command File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 2090, in set_speed File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 1034, in async_set_percentage File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 619, in _try_command File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 2090, in set_speed File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 1034, in async_set_percentage File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 619, in _try_command File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 2090, in set_speed File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 1034, in async_set_percentage File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 619, in _try_command File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 2090, in set_speed File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 1034, in async_set_percentage File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 619, in _try_command File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 2090, in set_speed File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 1034, in async_set_percentage File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 619, in _try_command File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 2090, in set_speed File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 1034, in async_set_percentage File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 619, in _try_command File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 2090, in set_speed File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 1034, in async_set_percentage File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 619, in _try_command File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 2090, in set_speed File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 1034, in async_set_percentage File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 619, in _try_command File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 2090, in set_speed File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 1034, in async_set_percentage File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 619, in _try_command File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 2090, in set_speed File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 1034, in async_set_percentage File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 619, in _try_command File "/config/custom_components/xiaomi_miio_fan/fan.py", line 2090, in set_speed

[syssi]

Could you enable the debug logging and provide another log capture?

Settings -> Devices & services -> Xiaomi Miio -> Enable debug logging (last item of the left tile)

[syssi]

I've pushed another fix. Please call the install update service another time, restart HA and give it another try.

[broekhuijsen]

Ok the log before the update

home-assistant_xiaomi_miio_fan_2024-08-31T14-29-15.682Z.log

The log after the update

home-assistant_xiaomi_miio_fan_2024-08-31T14-35-00.013Z.log

Unfortunately now it is back to the old behaviour of 25, 50, 75 and 100%

[syssi]

Interesting. I have to think about it. :-)

[broekhuijsen]

Take you time, while I enjoy the sunshine outside. 😀

[syssi]

It's confusing the p18 behaves different to the p33. Could you provide another debug log of the p18? Could you provide some screenshots too? Which lovelace card do you use exactly?

[broekhuijsen]

Here is the log for the P18

home-assistant_xiaomi_miio_fan_2024-08-31T15-04-03.817Z.log

I would expect the P33 and P18 to be equal, because the only difference seemed to be the battery. But apparently they are different.

For the testing I am not using any card. I just click on the entity in the integration and use the slider that pops up.

The living room fan is the P33

[broekhuijsen]

The strange thing is, all the other features are working fine, like setting the angle, the timer etc etc.

[broekhuijsen]

What is strange, is that the mode shows up as Normal with a Capital N for the P33, but a small N for the P18

`type: vertical-stack cards:

• features:
  • type: fan-speed type: tile entity: fan.living_room_fan show_entity_picture: false vertical: false
• type: entity state_color: true entity: fan.living_room_fan attribute: mode name: mode icon: ''
• show_name: true show_icon: false type: button tap_action: action: call-service service: script.living_room_fan_mode_toggle target: {} show_state: false name: Mode Select icon: mdi:toggle-switch
• type: entity entity: fan.living_room_fan attribute: angle name: swing range angle unit: º
• type: horizontal-stack cards:
  • show_name: true show_icon: false type: button tap_action: action: call-service service: xiaomi_miio_fan.fan_set_oscillation_angle target: {} data: entity_id: fan.living_room_fan angle: 30 name: '30' icon: '' show_state: false
  • show_name: true show_icon: false type: button tap_action: action: call-service service: xiaomi_miio_fan.fan_set_oscillation_angle target: {} data: entity_id: fan.living_room_fan angle: 60 name: '60' icon: mdi:axis-z-rotate-clockwise show_state: false
  • show_name: true show_icon: false type: button tap_action: action: call-service service: xiaomi_miio_fan.fan_set_oscillation_angle target: {} data: entity_id: fan.living_room_fan angle: 90 name: '90' icon: mdi:axis-z-rotate-clockwise show_state: false
  • show_name: true show_icon: false type: button tap_action: action: call-service service: xiaomi_miio_fan.fan_set_oscillation_angle target: {} data: entity_id: fan.living_room_fan angle: 120 name: '120' icon: mdi:axis-z-rotate-clockwise show_state: false
  • show_name: true show_icon: false type: button tap_action: action: call-service service: xiaomi_miio_fan.fan_set_oscillation_angle target: {} data: entity_id: fan.living_room_fan angle: 140 name: '140' icon: mdi:axis-z-rotate-clockwise show_state: false
• type: entity name: Timer entity: sensor.lr_fan_timer icon: mdi:fan-clock state_color: false
• type: horizontal-stack cards:
  • show_name: true show_icon: false type: button tap_action: action: call-service service: xiaomi_miio_fan.fan_set_delay_off target: {} data: delay_off_countdown: 0 entity_id: fan.living_room_fan name: 'Off'
  • show_name: true show_icon: false type: button tap_action: action: call-service service: xiaomi_miio_fan.fan_set_delay_off target: {} data: entity_id: fan.living_room_fan delay_off_countdown: 60 name: 1hr
  • show_name: true show_icon: false type: button tap_action: action: call-service service: xiaomi_miio_fan.fan_set_delay_off target: {} data: entity_id: fan.living_room_fan delay_off_countdown: 120 name: 2hrs
• type: horizontal-stack cards:
  • show_name: true show_icon: false type: button tap_action: action: call-service service: xiaomi_miio_fan.fan_set_delay_off target: {} data: entity_id: fan.living_room_fan delay_off_countdown: 180 name: 3hrs
  • show_name: true show_icon: false type: button tap_action: action: call-service service: xiaomi_miio_fan.fan_set_delay_off target: {} data: entity_id: fan.living_room_fan delay_off_countdown: 240 name: 4hrs
  • show_name: true show_icon: false type: button tap_action: action: call-service service: xiaomi_miio_fan.fan_set_delay_off target: {} data: entity_id: fan.living_room_fan delay_off_countdown: 300 name: 5hrs
• type: horizontal-stack cards:
  • show_name: true show_icon: false type: button tap_action: action: call-service service: xiaomi_miio_fan.fan_set_delay_off target: {} data: entity_id: fan.living_room_fan delay_off_countdown: 360 name: 6hrs
  • show_name: true show_icon: false type: button tap_action: action: call-service service: xiaomi_miio_fan.fan_set_delay_off target: {} data: entity_id: fan.living_room_fan delay_off_countdown: 420 name: 7hrs
  • show_name: true show_icon: false type: button tap_action: action: call-service service: xiaomi_miio_fan.fan_set_delay_off target: {} data: entity_id: fan.living_room_fan delay_off_countdown: 480 name: 8hrs
• type: horizontal-stack cards:
  • show_name: false show_icon: true type: button tap_action: action: call-service service: fan.set_direction target: entity_id: fan.living_room_fan data: direction: reverse icon: mdi:arrow-left-drop-circle name: Move Left show_state: true
  • show_name: false show_icon: true type: button tap_action: action: call-service service: fan.set_direction target: entity_id: fan.living_room_fan data: direction: forward name: Move Right icon: mdi:arrow-right-drop-circle show_state: true `

[syssi]

Note for myself:

Migrate away from speed parameter to percentage vs. preset_mode.