szanni / slideextract

extract slides from videos
https://szanni.org/slideextract/
BSD 2-Clause "Simplified" License
61 stars 14 forks source link

Make slideextract self-contained and cross-platform #1

Closed aminya closed 3 years ago

aminya commented 3 years ago
aminya commented 3 years ago

@szanni Check this out!

I am also interested to add continuous integration for providing binaries to make it easier for the average user to use this awesome tool.

szanni commented 3 years ago

Thanks for the effort and the hidden bug report but I hope this does not come off as too hash - pretty much the whole patch set won't fly...

Regarding windows: does anyone use windows command line tools for stuff like this these days? I though command line inclined people were using WSL2 these days anyways? Regarding mac: mac has macports and homebrew if anyone feels inclined to add support.

Regarding CI: the free services are changing all the time, I don't feel like constantly fixing this. A manual test suite would be amazing though. Automated CI IMO is warranted for bigger projects with many moving parts but for a small tool like this most likely more work than work saving.

And finally regarding binaries: there is no way I will distribute anything the like. If you feel so inclined - be my guest - I will not. This is due to opencv including tons of patented tech - video codecs and the like. It is beautiful we have open source projects like VLC media player, they are however backed by the VideoLan organization and a lot of people would jump in to fight a legal battle. I have no such backing and am not willing to take the risk.

aminya commented 3 years ago

NP