szhorvat / IGraphM

IGraph/M is the igraph interface for Mathematica
http://szhorvat.net/mathematica/IGraphM
Other
91 stars 17 forks source link

Add the ability to list all minimal edge cuts of a graph. #126

Open lichengzhang1 opened 1 year ago

lichengzhang1 commented 1 year ago

Add the ability to list all minimal edge cuts of a graph.

An edge cut is a set of edges that, if removed from a connected graph, will disconnect the graph. A minimal edge cut is an edge cut such that if any edge is put back in the graph, the graph will be reconnected. A minimum edge cut is an edge cut such that there is no other edge cut containing fewer edges. Note that a minimum edge cut is always minimal, but a minimal edge cut is not always minimum.

I see that IGFindMinimalCuts[g, s, t] can find all smallest-weight (i.e. minimum) edge cuts that disconnect vertex $t$ from vertex $s$. But what I'm looking for is all minimal edge cuts of a graph, and I did not see the corresponding function. (I don't yet know how a minimal edge cut of a graph is related to a minimal edge cut that disconnect some vertex to another vertex)

I have searched Literature [1] for the corresponding polynomial algorithm (which you can view). I have asked a similar question in mathematica stack and it also seems that there is no corresponding efficient code for finding all minimum edge cuts.

There appears to be more than one concern about this issue.

References

lichengzhang1 commented 1 year ago

From the discussion below, it appears that there is no polynomial algorithm for finding all minimal cuts. I feel that I have misread Literature [1], or the result of Literature [1] itself is wrong.

szhorvat commented 1 year ago

Can you please post this information at https://github.com/igraph/igraph/issues/2275? Let's continue the discussion there as the feature should probably be implemented in the core igraph library.

lichengzhang1 commented 1 year ago

OK. I have put the information in there. Best wishes!